In-state bidders would win state contracts

Summary#

Wisconsin Senate Joint Resolution 145 proposed amending the state constitution’s rule for contracts for state stationery and printing. It would require those contracts to go to the lowest bidder operating in Wisconsin, if there is one, unless federal law or an international agreement forbids that preference; the stated goal is to give Wisconsin-based bidders priority. The resolution failed, so it did not change the law.

  • The proposal covered stationery required for state use and printing authorized and required for state use.
  • It would have changed the existing lowest-bid rule: the lowest Wisconsin-operating bidder would get the contract even if an out-of-state bidder offered a lower price.
  • It would have kept the legislature’s ability to set a maximum price and the ban on state officers having a direct or indirect interest in these contracts.
  • A constitutional amendment would also have needed approval by a later legislature and ratification by voters before taking effect.

What it means for you#

  • Wisconsin businesses: If the proposal had become law, a business operating in Wisconsin could have won a covered contract as the lowest bidder in the state, even if another bidder outside Wisconsin offered a lower price.
  • Other bidders: An out-of-state bidder could have lost a covered contract despite offering the lowest price overall.
  • Taxpayers and state agencies: The proposal would have changed which bidder qualified as the lowest bidder for these contracts. It did not set a contract price or require the state to buy a particular amount.
  • Everyone: Because the resolution failed, it does not change current contracting rules.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The proposal included no spending amount, fee, fine, or estimate of changes to contract costs.
  • It did not create a new office or program.

What is unclear#

  • The proposal did not define what it means for a bidder to be “operating in” Wisconsin.
  • The available material does not explain how the state would determine which bidders meet that condition.
  • The proposal did not set out a process for applying the federal-law or international-agreement exception.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the proposal is that it would give Wisconsin-operating businesses priority when the state buys stationery or printing.
  • The state would still have to choose the lowest bidder within Wisconsin, rather than simply choosing any Wisconsin bidder.
  • The federal-law and international-agreement exception would limit the preference where it was prohibited.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the state could pay more than the lowest price available overall if a Wisconsin bidder’s price were higher than an out-of-state bidder’s.
  • The proposal did not define “operating in” Wisconsin or explain how eligibility would be checked, leaving important details unresolved.
  • The resolution failed, so the proposed preference did not take effect.