Procurement leans toward in-state firms

Summary#

Wisconsin SB 1118 would amend state procurement laws and create a new section of state law on local-government purchasing. It failed and is not law. Its stated goal is to increase purchases of products and services from businesses based in Wisconsin.

  • State purchasing officials and agencies would have to attempt to ensure that at least 20% of state procurement spending goes to Wisconsin-based businesses, and that the share does not fall below the previous year’s share.
  • The Department of Administration (DOA) would collect bidders’ principal-place-of-business information and publish it, along with an annual evaluation of state performance.
  • State specifications would have to allow for local products or services “to the extent possible,” as well as materials manufactured in the United States.
  • Local governments—including school and technical college districts—would have a goal of spending at least 20% of their annual purchases on Wisconsin-based businesses. They would also have a goal of not lowering the share spent on routine purchases from the previous year.
  • Local governments would have to publish an annual evaluation of progress unless their governing body officially opts out. The bill exempts purchases of stationery and printing materials from the purchasing preferences in the amended law.

What it means for you#

  • State agencies and bidders: If the bill had become law, agencies and designated purchasing agents would have had to try to meet the state spending goals. DOA would have had to collect and publish bidder location information. The bill does not set out a new application or award process.
  • Local governments and their residents: Local governments would have had purchasing goals and a public-evaluation duty, but could opt out of the evaluation requirements through official action. The 20% figure is a goal, not a required quota.
  • Wisconsin businesses: The bill defines a local product or service by where the seller’s principal place of business is located—not by where a product is made. It does not promise any business a contract.
  • Everyone: The bill does not create a new benefit, tax, fine, or independent agency.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill requires DOA to collect and publish information and evaluate state performance, but gives no staffing or cost estimate in the supplied material.
  • Local governments would have to evaluate and publish results unless they opt out. The supplied material gives no estimate of those costs.
  • The bill refers to a state and local fiscal estimate, but that estimate was not included in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the statutes being amended was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify all the changes against current law or how the bill’s new goals would interact with existing purchasing preferences.
  • The bill does not define “routine purchases,” which matters to the local-government goal.
  • It does not explain how “attempt to ensure” would be measured or what steps agencies must take to reach the state goals.
  • It does not set out how purchasing decisions would be scored, or how the public evaluations must be prepared.
  • The bill’s requirements would start in the fiscal year beginning after the relevant provisions took effect; the supplied material does not give an effective date.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to direct more public purchasing toward businesses based in Wisconsin.
  • A possible argument for the state target is that it sets a measurable goal while leaving agencies to make efforts rather than imposing a guaranteed quota.
  • Publishing bidder-location data and annual evaluations could make it easier for the public to see how much public purchasing goes to in-state businesses.
  • Local governments could set their own approach, and could opt out of the evaluation requirements.

Case against#

  • The state target is not a firm spending requirement: agencies must try to meet it, but the bill does not specify what they must do if they fall short.
  • The local targets are goals, not mandatory spending levels, and a local government can opt out of public evaluation. That may limit how much the goals change purchasing.
  • The bill does not say how the targets would affect price, quality, or other purchasing considerations, or how progress would be assessed consistently.
  • The undefined term “routine purchases” could make the local year-to-year goal difficult to interpret.