Require American-made materials in contracts

Summary#

Wisconsin SB 1139 would amend state procurement law and local-government contracting law; it did not become law because it failed. Its stated goal is to favor materials manufactured in the United States in government purchasing and contracts. The bill text keeps the existing condition that other factors be substantially equal for the state’s purchase preference, despite the bill analysis saying the preference would apply regardless.

  • For state purchases, it would describe eligible materials as those manufactured to the greatest extent in the United States and let the Department of Administration define that phrase by rule.
  • State contracts for construction, repair, or modification of public works or public improvement projects would have to require contractors to use materials manufactured in the United States, unless federal law or an international agreement prohibits it.
  • Each public contract entered into by a municipality would have to include the same kind of requirement, with the same federal-law and treaty exception.
  • Existing exceptions listed for the state purchasing preference would continue to apply, including when domestic materials are not available in sufficient or reasonably available quantities. The bill does not extend those listed exceptions to the new contract requirements.

What it means for you#

  • State and local governments: If the bill had passed, they would have had to include the required U.S.-manufactured-materials terms in covered contracts. The bill does not set out how governments would check or enforce contractors’ compliance.
  • Contractors: They would have been bound by those contract terms, unless federal law or an international agreement prohibited them. The bill does not define “manufactured in the United States” for these contract requirements.
  • Domestic manufacturers: The state purchasing preference and contract requirements could have created more opportunities to supply government projects. They would not guarantee sales.
  • General public and taxpayers: The bill did not directly change taxes, create a benefit, or transfer ownership of property. Because it failed, it made no change to current law.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill analysis says a state and local fiscal estimate would be printed with the bill, but that estimate was not supplied here.
  • The bill would have required the Department of Administration to define a term by rule. The materials give no estimate for that work or for contract administration.
  • The bill gives no estimate of how the requirements might affect government purchase or project prices.

What is unclear#

  • The bill text and its analysis conflict on whether the state purchase preference would still require other factors to be substantially equal. The bill text retains that condition.
  • The bill lets the Department of Administration define “manufactured to the greatest extent” for state purchases, but the materials do not give that definition or explain when a rule would take effect.
  • The bill does not define “manufactured in the United States” for state or municipal contract requirements, or set out compliance checks, enforcement, or remedies.
  • The supplied text of the existing statutes is not included. The analysis describes some current rules and exceptions, but the full interaction with current law could not be verified.
  • The bill gives no start date. In any event, it failed and is not law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to direct more government purchasing toward materials manufactured in the United States.
  • Requiring contract terms for public projects could make the requirement apply to materials used by contractors, not only materials bought directly by the state.
  • A state preference would still be limited by the equal-factors condition in the bill text and by listed exceptions, including when domestic materials are not reasonably available in sufficient quantities.

Case against#

  • One concern is that contract requirements could limit governments’ options when U.S.-manufactured materials are unavailable or costly; the contract provisions do not include the bill’s listed availability exception.
  • The bill does not define “manufactured in the United States” for contracts or explain how compliance would be checked, leaving important practical questions unanswered.
  • The state purchase preference’s equal-factors condition is described differently in the bill analysis and bill text, which could cause confusion about the intended rule.