Voters could propose laws by petition

Summary#

SJR-146 proposes amending the Wisconsin Constitution to let voters reject laws and propose laws and constitutional amendments by petition. Its stated goal is to reserve referendum and initiative powers to the people. The resolution failed at first consideration and is not law; a constitutional amendment would also need approval by a second legislature and ratification by voters.

  • A referendum petition could target an entire legislative act, part of an act, or an appropriation item. It would need signatures equal to at least 4% of the vote for governor at the last gubernatorial election.
  • An initiative petition would need signatures equal to at least 6% of that vote for a proposed law, or 8% for a constitutional amendment. It must include the full text and cover one subject, stated in its title.
  • The state agency that administers elections would have to verify petition signatures and order qualifying proposals onto the ballot at a general election at least 120 days after filing.
  • A measure approved by voters would take effect 30 days after election results are certified, unless it sets a different date. The legislature could not change an initiative law for two years after publication; after that, changing it would require a two-thirds vote in each house.
  • Paid signature gathering could not be paid by, or pay, someone based directly or indirectly on the number of signatures obtained.

What it means for you#

  • Wisconsin voters: If the amendment took effect, qualified electors could sign petitions to put laws or constitutional amendments before voters, or to seek a vote rejecting a law or part of one. The bill does not itself create a petition process now, because it failed.
  • People proposing a measure: You would need to meet the signature threshold, file the full text on paper, and meet the single-subject and timing rules. At an elector’s request, the elections agency would have to prepare the proposal in proper form and make it public.
  • People gathering signatures: You could be paid for signature gathering, but not based on the number of signatures obtained.
  • State election administrators: The agency would have to verify petitions and arrange the required votes. The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or services for the public.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the supplied material.

  • The elections agency would have to verify signatures, arrange elections for qualifying petitions, and prepare initiative text in proper form when an elector requests it.
  • The bill gives no estimate for staffing or election-administration costs. It does not set a fee or appropriate a specific amount of money.

What is unclear#

  • The current Wisconsin Constitution was not supplied, so I could not verify which related rules or powers already exist or exactly how this proposal would change current law.
  • The bill does not name the elections agency or set detailed rules for signature verification, challenges, appeals, or deadlines for those steps.
  • It does not explain how the agency would decide whether a rejected proposal is “substantially the same” as a later one, or what review would be available.
  • “Proper form” is not explained in the resolution; it refers to rules to be provided by law.
  • The resolution does not estimate costs or explain how the new duties would be funded.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the amendment is that it would give voters a direct way to propose laws and constitutional changes, rather than relying only on the legislature.
  • Referendums could give voters a way to reject an act, a part of an act, or a specific appropriation item.
  • The signature thresholds, single-subject rule, and election timing requirements set conditions for putting a proposal to a statewide vote.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the resolution creates major election-administration duties without estimating their cost or explaining how the agency would handle them.
  • The bill does not set out detailed review, challenge, or appeal procedures for petitions, which could leave important decisions unclear.
  • Initiative laws would be difficult for the legislature to change: they would be protected from amendment or repeal for two years and would later require a two-thirds vote in each house.