Paper ballots and hand counting mandate

Summary#

SF-184, “Prohibition on electronic voting equipment-2,” would amend Wyoming’s Election Code to require paper ballots and hand counting, while repealing many provisions for electronic voting systems and electronic pollbooks. Its stated goal is to make elections use paper ballots counted by people. The bill’s status is listed as failed, so it did not become law; I could not verify the current rules because the parent Election Code was not supplied.

  • County clerks would have to arrange for paper ballots to be hand counted. The bill sets out a method using bipartisan counting teams and tally sheets.
  • Electronic pollbooks could not be used by election judges, although clerks could still use electronic systems to prepare pollbooks.
  • An accessible voting machine would remain available at each polling place. It could help a voter mark a paper ballot, but could not count votes or connect to the internet or communicate.
  • The bill would require a post-election audit of at least 5% of ballots, with the sample size determined using a University of Wyoming formula.
  • It would expand election observers’ ability to watch voter registration and hand counting, and would require testing of the hand-counting, tabulating and reporting procedure before an election.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: If enacted, you would generally mark a paper ballot. The bill allows an accessible machine to help voters with disabilities mark a paper ballot. It does not say that this machine would count votes.
  • County clerks and election workers: They would have to organize hand counting, supply ballots and counting materials, and test the counting procedure before elections. The bill sets out a counting method in which one team reads and checks votes and another records them.
  • Election observers: They could observe voter registration and hand-counting procedures and make written notes. They could not challenge voters or election judges, campaign at the polling place, or disrupt the process.
  • Taxpayers and local governments: The bill gives no estimate of what the required staffing, supplies, training or procedures would cost.
  • Everyone: The bill’s text sets July 1, 2025 as its proposed start date, but because it failed, that date did not make these changes law.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill would require election workers and counting boards to carry out hand counting, but provides no estimate of staffing or other costs.
  • It says the political subdivision holding a bond election must pay its actual election costs, or a share of costs for a combined election. The supplied material does not show how this compares with current law.

What is unclear#

  • The current Election Code was not supplied, so I could not verify which rules and equipment the bill would replace or how much of its wording would be new.
  • The supplied bill text contains overlapping edits and some conflicting wording. For example, it gives different possible minimum sizes for counting boards at counting centers. The exact requirements are therefore unclear from this copy.
  • The text is unclear about when counting would start: one provision says counting begins after the polls close, but also says it begins one hour before closing.
  • The bill does not fully explain how hand counting would work for absentee ballots, ballots counted at a central location, or ballots from overseas voters. It preserves an electronic transmission exception for overseas ballots.
  • The bill does not give a detailed plan for staffing, training, timelines, or resolving disagreements during a count. It also does not explain how its rules would work alongside any existing election processes.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that paper ballots provide a physical record that election workers can inspect and count.
  • The bill’s counting method uses workers from different political parties and requires separate tally sheets, which could provide checks during counting.
  • Testing the process before an election and allowing observers to watch could make parts of the counting process more visible.
  • Keeping an accessible voting machine for marking paper ballots recognizes that some voters may need help marking a ballot, while keeping the machine separate from vote counting.

Case against#

  • One concern is that hand counting every ballot would require substantial worker time and coordination. The bill does not estimate the cost or explain how counties would meet the staffing requirement.
  • The bill sets counting and audit requirements but leaves important practical details unclear, including timing and some counting-board requirements.
  • Limiting accessible machines to marking paper ballots may change how voters who rely on those machines cast a vote. The bill does not explain how counties would ensure accessible voting under the new process.
  • The bill does not explain how its requirements would fit with existing election procedures or how counting disagreements would be resolved.