Paper ballots default; hand recounts for close races

Summary#

SF-190, titled Election transparency, would amend Wyoming’s Election Code and create a new rule for paper ballots. Its stated goal is to allow time for hand-count recounts. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • Counties would have to make paper ballots the default for in-person voting. Ballots would still be tabulated automatically from voters’ marks; voters could choose an electronic ballot-marking device, but it could not be the default.
  • People registering to vote would have to provide proof of U.S. citizenship from a specified list of documents. The list includes certain state and tribal ID cards, a U.S. passport, citizenship or naturalization certificates, and a U.S. birth certificate.
  • Certain close elections would get mandatory hand-count recounts. The bill sets different margin thresholds for federal, statewide and legislative races, and other offices; not every recount would be by hand.
  • The bill would change election dates and canvass deadlines. It sets the primary for the first Tuesday after the second Monday in August, and sets county and state canvass deadlines at the second Friday and third Wednesday after an election.
  • The bill would create an election recount account, appropriate $200,000 to it, and make its funds continuously available to the secretary of state for administering hand recounts.

What it means for you#

  • Voters registering: You would have to provide one of the listed documents as proof of citizenship. The bill does not say how a person without an accepted document could register.
  • Voters casting ballots in person: You would receive a paper ballot as the default. You could choose an electronic ballot-marking device; the bill requires those devices to meet federal accessibility rules.
  • County clerks and counties: They would have to provide paper ballots for in-person voting and conduct required recounts by hand. The bill also allows clerks to appoint a counting board of at least three members for recounts.
  • Candidates and people seeking a ballot-proposition recount: A candidate’s recount request would have to say whether it should be by hand or electronic equipment. The bill changes when some recounts are required and how recounts are paid for.
  • Absentee voters: Where a county uses the specified courthouse absentee-polling option, it would be open on normal courthouse business days from 21 days before the election through the close of business the day before. The bill does not directly change who is eligible to vote.

Money#

The bill would provide $200,000 for hand-recount costs, but the available material gives no estimate of total costs.

  • The money would come from the state general fund. The account would not revert, and its funds would remain available for the stated recount purpose. Investment earnings would go to the general fund.
  • Counties would pay for recounts they initiate or that are required under the bill. The secretary of state would pay for recounts the secretary initiates.
  • For candidate-requested recounts, the text appears to let county clerks set deposits up to $1,000 for an electronic recount or $5,000 for a hand count. If the result does not change, the requester could owe recount costs up to the deposit.
  • The bill requires counties to provide paper ballots and recount staffing, but gives no cost estimate or staffing estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The current Election Code was not supplied, so the changes described here cannot be fully compared with current law. In particular, the available material does not establish which paper-ballot or recount rules already exist.
  • The bill does not explain what happens if someone registering cannot provide one of the listed citizenship documents, or how existing registrations would be treated.
  • It does not set detailed procedures, standards, timelines or oversight for hand counts.
  • It does not explain how the $200,000 appropriation compares with likely recount costs, or whether more funding would be needed.
  • The bill changes election dates and canvass deadlines, but the available text does not show how those changes compare with current dates.
  • The bill failed; it therefore creates no active duties or funding.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to provide a paper record for in-person votes while retaining automatic tabulation for ordinary counting.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that hand recounts could provide another way to check results in specified close races.
  • Setting aside money for recounts could help cover some of the cost when hand recounts are required.
  • Requiring proof of citizenship would make the stated citizenship qualification for voter registration subject to document checks.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires specified proof of citizenship but does not provide an alternative for people who cannot obtain or produce a listed document.
  • Hand-count recounts would require staff and time, but the bill sets no detailed counting standards or staffing plan. The $200,000 appropriation may or may not cover the costs.
  • The bill adds duties for county election offices without estimating their paper-ballot, equipment or staffing costs.
  • It is unclear how the new rules would fit with existing election procedures, since the current Election Code was not provided.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1487700

    Passed30 members voted

    3rd Reading:Passed 29-1-1-0-0

    FOR · 29AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    29For

    • Republican28
    • Democratic1

    1Against

    • Democratic1

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1484271

    Passed5 members voted

    S07 - Corporations:Recommend Amend and Do Pass 5-0-0-0-0

    FOR · 5

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    5For

    • Republican5

    0Against