Hand-counted paper ballots bill fails

Summary#

SF-108, “Election purity and hand count-2,” would create a new article in Wyoming’s Election Code and amend or repeal many existing election rules. Its stated goal is to move Wyoming elections to paper ballots counted by hand in public view. The bill failed, so it did not make these changes law.

  • County clerks would have to use paper ballots that people can read and count by hand. Electronic voting equipment—including tabulators, scanners and e-pollbooks—would be prohibited, with a narrow exception for federally permitted accessible devices to produce a human-readable ballot for manual counting.
  • The Secretary of State would have to set statewide rules for ballots, security, custody, hand counting, reconciliation, training and observation. Counties would need the Secretary’s approval for their counting method.
  • Counting teams would include at least four people from at least two political affiliations. The bill would require public observation, video and audio recording, and publication of county recordings and count totals.
  • County clerks would have to document ballot custody and reconcile ballot totals. If a discrepancy could not be determined beyond a reasonable doubt, the county canvassing board would have to declare affected results void.
  • The bill would apply to Wyoming elections after January 1, 2026, if it became law. It would also change election offenses and penalties.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: You would vote on a paper ballot. Absentee and early ballots, as well as in-person ballots, would be counted by hand. Provisional ballots would be counted separately after eligibility is confirmed.
  • Voters using accessible devices: The devices could produce a human-readable ballot, but could not tabulate the vote; the ballot would be counted by hand.
  • County clerks and election workers: They would have to follow new statewide standards, document ballot transfers, reconcile totals, and complete required training. Counting would begin as soon as practicable after polls close and continue without undue delay.
  • Public and observers: Members of the public, candidates and political parties could observe counting under rules meant to prevent interference. Counting recordings would be posted online and kept for at least five years.
  • Election officials: An official or county clerk who knowingly violated the new rules could face a fine of up to $5,000 per violation. Other changes would make some election-code violations by officials felonies and could lead to removal from office.
  • Current law: The existing Election Code was not supplied, so I could not verify which of these requirements would be entirely new or how they would change current procedures.

Money#

No publicly available information on an estimated cost.

  • The bill would require county clerks to maintain custody records and video surveillance, and to record and retain counting footage. It would also require the Secretary of State to make rules and establish training. The bill gives no cost estimate, staffing estimate or dedicated funding for these duties.
  • The bill would require ballots and election materials to be stored under continuous video surveillance for at least 24 months. Counting recordings would have to be retained for at least five years; recount recordings, at least eight years.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out the full counting and security rules. It directs the Secretary of State to use an outside set of “Gold Standard Elections” guidelines, including versions revised after April 11, 2025. Those guidelines were not supplied.
  • It does not estimate how many workers, counting centers, cameras or other resources counties would need.
  • Terms such as “extraordinary circumstances” and a discrepancy that cannot be resolved “beyond a reasonable doubt” are not explained in the bill.
  • The bill would alter the post-election audit rules, but the current Election Code was not supplied, so the full change from current audit practice cannot be verified.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that paper ballots counted by people could make the counting process easier for the public to observe and check.
  • Requiring independent tallies, ballot reconciliation and custody records could help identify where totals differ or records are incomplete.
  • Public observation and published recordings could give the public more direct access to how ballots are handled and counted.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires substantial changes in counting, storage, recording and training but provides no cost or staffing estimate.
  • Manual counting and the required records and recordings could take significant time and resources. The bill sets deadlines but does not explain how counties should handle a count that cannot meet them.
  • The bill relies on outside guidelines that may be revised over time, but does not include those guidelines or explain how changes to them would affect the rules.
  • The bill gives election officials a short, high-stakes standard for unresolved discrepancies—voiding affected results if the reason cannot be determined beyond a reasonable doubt—without detailing the investigation process.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1631702

    Defeated31 members voted

    Failed Introduction 9-22-0-0-0

    AGAINST · 22FOR · 9

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    22Against

    • Republican20
    • Democratic2

    9For

    • Republican9