Electricity choice would let customers pick resources

Summary#

HB-174, the “Wyoming choice electric program,” would add a new section to Wyoming’s public-utilities law. It would require the Wyoming Public Service Commission to make rules requiring electric utilities to offer customers choices among the resource types used to generate or buy electricity. The bill’s stated goal is to establish a choice electric program, but HB-174 failed and is not law.

  • Utilities, including city- and town-owned utilities and cooperative electric utilities, would have to offer electricity by each resource type they offer, or by combinations of those types.
  • The commission’s rules would require utilities to let customers choose different percentages of resource types and provide specified pricing and cost information.
  • Utilities would also have to provide information about a standard rate using all resource types for customers who do not join the program.
  • A utility could not use the program to serve customers outside the area in its certificate of convenience and necessity.
  • The commission could authorize utilities to recover program administration costs and costs associated with customers’ selected resource-type percentages from participating customers.

What it means for you#

  • Electric customers: If the bill had become law, your utility would have had to offer the choices required by the commission’s rules. The bill does not itself set the choices, prices, or process for making them.
  • Customers choosing certain resource types: If a utility offered a resource type that is not reliable or dispatchable (able to be controlled to meet demand), it would have to provide information about other resources it buys to meet demand and costs customers might incur because of those purchases.
  • Customers who do not participate: Utilities would have to provide information on a rate based on all resource types they offer.
  • Electric utilities: The bill would require them to establish a program under commission rules and provide the information those rules require. It would not let them expand service beyond their certified territory.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, it creates no current duty, choice, or rate change.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill would require the commission to make rules by January 1, 2027, but it provides no staffing or implementation cost estimate.
  • The commission could, but would not have to, authorize utilities to recover certain program costs from participating customers.
  • Utilities would have to disclose the actual cost of each resource type without grants, tax exemptions, or subsidies received for that resource type.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves the program’s detailed rules to the commission, including how customers would choose percentages and how the program would be administered.
  • It does not set deadlines, an application process, or a way to challenge a utility’s decision.
  • It is unclear how the program would interact with any existing customer choice or rate arrangements. The supplied material does not include the current law needed to check that.
  • The bill refers to existing legal definitions of “reliable” and “dispatchable,” but those definitions were not supplied.
  • It does not explain whether customers’ selections would change the physical electricity delivered or how resource types would be assigned for billing.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that customers could choose the mix of resource types used to calculate their electricity purchase, rather than only buying at a rate based on all types offered.
  • Required cost and pricing information could help customers compare options, including costs that would otherwise be reflected in the standard rate.
  • Requiring participation by utilities across different ownership types could make the program available to customers served by those utilities, subject to the rules.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill leaves important details—such as customer selection and administration—to future rules, so the choices and their practical value are not clear from the bill.
  • Participants could face added costs: the commission could allow utilities to recover administration costs and costs tied to selected resource-type percentages from them.
  • The required cost figures may be harder to compare with a customer’s actual bill because the bill requires disclosure of resource costs before grants, tax exemptions, or subsidies.
  • It is unclear how the program would work alongside existing rates or arrangements, and the supplied material does not show whether those would change.