Federal Interests Shift in Forest Parcel

Summary#

S. 277 is a proposed federal law concerning about 0.62 acres in Chickasaw State Forest in Chester County, Tennessee. It would require the Secretary of Agriculture to release the United States’ reversionary interest in that land and convey the federal mineral interest to Tennessee; it overrides certain requirements in the Bankhead-Jones Farm Tenant Act and the Federal Land Policy and Management Act for these transactions. The bill’s stated goal is to address a reported encroachment by Bethel Baptist Church onto state-owned land.

  • The federal reversionary interest would be released without payment. Under the deed described in the bill, that interest could take effect if the land stopped being used for public purposes.
  • The federal mineral interest in the parcel would be conveyed to Tennessee by quitclaim deed (a transfer without a promise that the title is sound), without payment or warranty.
  • The Agriculture Secretary would have to make both transfers without an appraisal or environmental or similar review. The mineral transfer also would not require an exploration program or findings about mineral values.
  • Tennessee would have to pay the United States’ administrative costs for each transfer.
  • The bill does not transfer the land to the church. It is not yet law.

What it means for you#

  • Tennessee: The state would receive the federal mineral interest and the release of the federal reversionary interest. It must pay the federal government’s administrative costs.
  • Bethel Baptist Church: The bill names the church in its findings, but does not transfer land to it or set out a boundary process.
  • People using the state forest: The bill removes the federal reversion tied to continued public use, but does not itself direct Tennessee to change the land’s use.
  • Other members of the public: The bill concerns this specific parcel, not a general change to federal or state land rules.

Money#

No total cost estimate is provided; Tennessee would have to reimburse any administrative costs the United States incurs in carrying out the transfers.

  • The federal government would receive no payment for the reversionary or mineral interests.
  • No estimate of administrative costs is provided. No publicly available information.
  • The bill does not state the value of the mineral interest or require an appraisal to determine it.

What is unclear#

  • The referenced 2019 map is not included in the supplied material, so the parcel’s exact boundaries cannot be checked here.
  • The bill does not define “public purposes,” the condition tied to the federal reversionary interest.
  • It sets no deadline or other process details for completing the transfers.
  • The bill gives no information about mineral deposits or their value. No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address a reported encroachment involving a very small parcel and a federal interest created by a 1955 deed.
  • Releasing the reversionary interest and transferring the mineral interest could simplify the federal-state interests in the parcel.
  • A possible argument for waiving appraisals and reviews is that those steps may be disproportionate for a parcel of about 0.62 acres.

Case against#

  • The federal government would give up both interests without payment, while the bill requires no appraisal or assessment of mineral value.
  • The bill removes the federal reversion tied to public use without requiring Tennessee to keep the land in public use.
  • The bill does not require environmental or similar review, or an exploration program to establish what minerals may be present.