Audits urged to improve compliance

Summary#

SCR-174 is a concurrent resolution, not a bill that changes state law. It urges the Hawaii Campaign Spending Commission to take steps to improve candidate committees’ compliance with campaign finance laws; its stated goal is fuller compliance. It is introduced and referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee, so it has not been adopted.

  • The Commission is urged to automatically audit candidate committees that spend more than $500,000 during an election period.
  • It is urged to subsidize independent audits for candidate committees that want them.
  • It is urged to adopt rules defining what counts as a “substantially defective or deficient” report under existing law.
  • It is urged to offer in-person training more often and outside normal business hours, and to take other actions within its power to support compliance.
  • The resolution does not itself require the Commission to take these steps, change campaign finance laws, or create an enforceable duty.

What it means for you#

  • Campaign Spending Commission: If the resolution is adopted, it would urge the Commission to take the listed steps, but would not legally require it to do so.
  • Candidate committees spending more than $500,000 in an election period: The resolution urges automatic audits for these committees. It does not itself set up an audit process.
  • Candidate committees seeking independent audits: The Commission is urged to subsidize their audit costs. The resolution does not say how to request a subsidy or who would qualify.
  • Candidate committees and campaign volunteers: The Commission is urged to provide in-person training more often and outside normal business hours.
  • The public: The resolution does not directly change voting, campaign contributions, or the rules for candidates.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution urges the Commission to subsidize independent audits, but gives no amount, funding source, or limit.
  • More audits, subsidies, rulemaking, or training could require Commission resources; the resolution gives no estimate.
  • It does not appropriate money or set a fee or tax.

What is unclear#

  • What counts as an “election period” for the proposed $500,000 audit threshold is not explained.
  • The resolution does not say how automatic audits would be selected or conducted, or how often they would happen.
  • It does not set eligibility rules or a process for committees seeking subsidized audits.
  • It does not set a deadline for the Commission to adopt rules or expand training.
  • The resolution’s statements about current law and Commission practices are not independently verified here; the statutes it cites and the current rules were not supplied.

Case for#

  • The resolution appears intended to address gaps in auditing, reporting guidance, and training described in its recitals.
  • Automatic audits above a stated spending threshold could focus audit attention on committees with higher spending.
  • Subsidies could make independent audits more accessible to committees that want them.
  • Clearer rules for defective reports and more training could help committees understand how to file compliant reports.

Case against#

  • The resolution urges action but does not require it, set deadlines, or ensure that any of its proposals will happen.
  • It proposes subsidizing audits without saying how much public money that would require or which committees would receive it.
  • It does not explain how audits would be carried out or how the Commission would handle findings.
  • The $500,000 threshold and undefined “election period” could leave questions about which committees would be audited.