Securities protections expanded for investors

Summary#

The Securities Amendment Act amends Manitoba’s Securities Act; it does not create a separate securities law. Its stated goal is to add investor protections and give the Manitoba Securities Commission powers over benchmarks and investment-industry dispute resolution. The bill says it starts on royal assent, but the supplied copy leaves the assent date blank.

  • Promotional activity would be subject to new bans on certain representations, false or misleading important information, and unfair practices. Some claims about a security’s or derivative’s listing would require the Director’s prior written permission.
  • The Commission could designate benchmarks and their administrators, and could order a person or company to provide information to a designated benchmark administrator. Administrators, contributors and users would have to follow requirements set by regulations.
  • The Commission could designate a dispute resolution service for complaints between registrants and their clients. The service must provide a fair and efficient process for complaints referred to it, and may make binding orders, including compensation orders.
  • The bill adds a ban on knowingly or reasonably ought-to-be-known assistance in contravening securities law. It also extends specified civil-liability rules to other prescribed disclosure documents and people who consent to information in them.
  • If the Commission opens a hearing that includes a compensation claim for a loss, a court case seeking compensation for the same loss must be stayed until the Commission decides whether to order compensation.

What it means for you#

  • Investors: A person or company generally could not claim that they or someone else would resell or repurchase a security, refund its price, refund money paid for a derivative, or take on a derivative obligation. The bill includes exceptions, such as where the security or derivative itself provides for the purchase, redemption or refund. During promotional activity, claims about future prices or values would be banned. Claims about a planned or expected exchange listing would need the Director’s prior written permission.
  • Investors and promoters: During promotional activity, people and companies could not make important false or misleading statements, leave out information needed to make them not misleading, or use the listed unfair practices. Those practices include unreasonable pressure, taking advantage of a person’s inability to protect their interests, and imposing inequitable terms.
  • Investors with complaints against registrants: A designated service could order a registrant to take steps such as correcting conduct, changing a practice, forgiving or varying a debt, changing or setting aside a contract, or paying compensation. These are powers, not guaranteed remedies. Only complaints referred to the service are covered; the bill does not require every complaint to go there.
  • Investors pursuing compensation: Once a Commission hearing includes a claim for the same loss, a court case for that loss is paused until the Commission decides whether to order compensation. A claimant may start a court case only to preserve a limitation period while the hearing is underway. “Same loss” includes unclaimed losses from the same transaction.
  • Benchmark administrators, contributors and users: They would be subject to requirements set by regulation. The Commission could also order information to be provided to an administrator of a designated benchmark.
  • People named in disclosure documents: The bill extends certain civil-liability provisions to other disclosure documents prescribed by regulation. The explanatory note says a person who consents to information in such a document may face the same liability as if the information were in a prospectus.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The bill gives the Commission new regulatory and oversight powers, but supplies no estimate of staffing or operating costs.
  • A designated dispute resolution service may order a registrant to compensate a complainant or provide other financial remedies. The bill does not set out the amounts; compensation is subject to regulations.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves many details to future regulations, including benchmark requirements, which benchmarks may be designated, and possible limits or rules for compensation orders.
  • The bill does not set out how complaints are referred, how the dispute service makes decisions, or what limits apply to compensation. It also does not set out a process for reviewing the service’s final orders; it says they are not reviewable by the Commission.
  • The definition of promotional activity is broad, but regulations may exclude activities or add requirements and restrictions. Those regulations are not supplied.
  • The Securities Act as it currently stands was not supplied, so the full difference from current law cannot be verified. The explanatory note describes intended changes.
  • The supplied text does not give the date of royal assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect investors from misleading promotions, pressure tactics and claims that could suggest an investment is guaranteed or will be listed.
  • Rules for benchmark data, conflicts of interest and record-keeping could help address risks when benchmarks affect prices, payments or investment performance.
  • A designated dispute service could offer clients another way to seek remedies without relying only on court proceedings.
  • Extending disclosure-document liability could give investors a way to pursue people who consent to information used to sell investments.

Case against#

  • Many important rules depend on future regulations, so the bill itself does not show the full duties or costs that businesses and others would face.
  • The dispute service could make binding orders with wide effects, including changing contracts or debts. The bill does not set out all decision procedures or limits in the text supplied.
  • Pausing court cases while the Commission considers compensation could delay a claimant’s court claim, even though the bill allows a court filing to preserve a limitation period.
  • The bill gives the Commission broad powers to designate benchmarks and services and set conditions. The supplied material does not explain how often those powers would be used or how much oversight would cost.