Bill would let terminally ill end life

Summary#

HB 3497, the “Death with Dignity Act,” would amend Missouri’s chapters on health and criminal law by adding 27 sections. It would create a process for some terminally ill adults to obtain medication and end their lives by self-administering it; the bill’s stated goal is to let them do so in a “humane and dignified manner.” The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • An adult could qualify only if they are competent, a Missouri resident, and have a medically confirmed terminal disease expected to cause death within six months. They must request the medication voluntarily and meet the bill’s other requirements.
  • The process requires an attending physician and a consulting physician to assess the patient, a written request witnessed by two people, two oral requests at least 15 days apart, and at least 48 hours between signing the written request and the prescription. Counseling is required if a physician believes a mental health condition may impair the patient’s judgment.
  • The Department of Health and Senior Services must review records, collect required reports, make rules, and publish an annual statistical report. The bill does not create a separate agency.
  • Health care providers would not have to take part. A provider that refuses must transfer the patient’s relevant medical records to a new provider on the patient’s request. Providers could prohibit participation on their premises or within work or contract duties if they give notice.
  • The bill would protect qualifying participants from civil or criminal liability and professional discipline for good-faith actions, except in cases of willful misconduct or gross negligence. It would also create an affirmative defense to certain homicide prosecutions for conduct expressly authorized by the bill.
  • The bill says this process does not authorize lethal injection, mercy killing, or active euthanasia. It also bars denying certain life-insurance benefits solely because a qualified patient self-administered the medication under the bill.

What it means for you#

  • Adults with a terminal disease: If you meet the eligibility and process requirements, you could request a prescription. You could rescind your request at any time and in any manner. The bill does not require a physician or other provider to participate.
  • Physicians and other health care providers: The bill would set duties for attending and consulting physicians, including checking competence, voluntariness, diagnosis, and informed decision-making. Providers may decline to participate; a provider that does so must transfer records on request.
  • Health care facilities: A facility could bar participation on its premises or within work or contract duties after giving notice. The bill limits that bar for some activities outside the facility or outside a person’s work duties.
  • Families and witnesses: The attending physician must recommend that the patient notify next of kin, but the patient’s request cannot be denied for declining or being unable to do so. Witnesses must attest to the patient’s competence and voluntary choice; at least one must meet restrictions on family ties, inheritance, and facility employment.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The department would have new reporting, review, rulemaking, and publication duties. If a person ends their life under the bill in a public place, a government entity that incurs costs may seek to recover them from the person’s estate.

Money#

The bill requires government and health-care administration, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • The Department of Health and Senior Services must review records annually, collect reports, make rules, and publish annual statistics; the bill does not estimate staffing or costs.
  • Providers must file prescriptions and related documentation with the department.
  • Government entities may seek costs and reasonable legal fees from an estate if the death occurs in a public place and the entity incurs costs.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the amended chapters was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify what protections, duties, or criminal rules already exist or how much of this bill would be new.
  • The bill does not give an effective date.
  • The department must make rules, but the bill does not set out the full reporting forms or other administrative details.
  • The bill does not explain how providers would handle disagreements about competence, voluntariness, or whether a patient meets the eligibility rules.
  • It is unclear how the new process would interact with existing health-care programs or facility policies.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give some competent adults with a short life expectancy a choice about how to face the end of life.
  • Requiring two physicians to assess the diagnosis and competence, informing patients about alternatives, and allowing the patient to rescind are safeguards built into the process.
  • The bill requires public annual statistics, which could provide information about how the process is used.
  • The bill protects patients from losing certain life-insurance benefits solely because they used the authorized process.

Case against#

  • The bill creates a serious, irreversible option, while leaving many practical rules to the department and the judgments of physicians.
  • The bill does not estimate the cost of the department’s duties or explain how they would be staffed.
  • A provider or facility may refuse participation, so a patient’s ability to use the process could depend on finding willing providers and an available setting.
  • The bill gives broad liability protection to people involved when acting in good faith, with exceptions for willful misconduct and gross negligence; how that standard would apply in particular cases is not explained.