Auto-renewal disclosures would require consent

Summary#

HB 3519, titled “Changes the law regarding automatically renewed transactions by requiring certain notice be given to the consumer,” would add a new section to Missouri’s Chapter 407 on consumer protection. Its stated goal is to require certain disclosures and cancellation options for automatic-renewal and continuous-service offers. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • Businesses offering these plans to Missouri consumers would have to clearly show the terms before the purchase agreement is completed and get the consumer’s affirmative consent before charging them.
  • For a free trial or gift offer, businesses would have to explain the price after the trial or how the price changes. They would also have to let the consumer cancel before paying.
  • Businesses would have to give consumers a retainable acknowledgment with the terms, cancellation policy, and cancellation instructions, and provide at least one listed cancellation method.
  • For a material change to accepted terms, businesses would have to give written notice and cancellation information before the change takes effect.
  • The Attorney General may sue for violations. A business found liable would face a civil penalty of at least $50,000 per violation.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: Before agreeing to an automatic-renewal offer, you would have to be shown its terms and affirmatively consent. You would receive cancellation information and at least one way to cancel, such as an email address or toll-free number.
  • Consumers with a free trial or gift offer: The business would have to explain what you will pay after the trial or how the price will change, and let you cancel before you pay.
  • Consumers whose plan terms change: You would have to receive written notice of a material change and information on how to cancel before it takes effect.
  • Businesses: You would have to meet the disclosure, consent, acknowledgment, and cancellation requirements. The bill says these requirements generally apply before the initial order is completed, with exceptions for the acknowledgment and notice of a material change. It is unclear how that timing rule affects the cancellation requirement after the initial order.
  • The bill does not ban automatic renewals or require refunds.

Money#

No publicly available information on implementation costs or expected revenue.

  • Businesses may face costs to update offer disclosures, acknowledgments, and cancellation methods; the bill provides no estimate.
  • The bill authorizes the Attorney General to sue and seek penalties of at least $50,000 per violation. A penalty would depend on an action and finding of liability; the bill does not estimate how many cases or penalties there might be.

What is unclear#

  • The materials do not include the current text of Chapter 407, so I could not verify which similar protections already apply under current Missouri law.
  • The bill does not define “material change” or “violation,” or set a maximum civil penalty per violation.
  • It is unclear whether the cancellation requirement continues to apply after the initial order, given the bill’s rule that the requirements generally apply only before that order is completed.
  • The bill does not specify how the Attorney General would decide how many violations occurred in a case.
  • No publicly available information on when the bill would take effect.

Case for#

  • Clear terms before consent could help consumers understand what they are agreeing to and what they will pay after a trial or promotion.
  • A retainable acknowledgment and a stated cancellation method could make it easier for consumers to find the terms and end a subscription.
  • Advance notice of material changes could give consumers a chance to cancel before new terms take effect.

Case against#

  • The bill sets a minimum penalty of $50,000 per violation but does not define “violation” or set a maximum, leaving the possible total penalty unclear.
  • The bill does not explain what counts as a “material change,” which could lead to uncertainty for businesses and consumers.
  • The timing rule may make it unclear whether the required cancellation options must remain available after the initial order is completed.