Biometric privacy rules for private entities

Summary#

HB 3537, the Enhanced Personal Privacy Act, would add new sections to Chapter 1 of Missouri law. Its stated goal, suggested by its title, is to enhance personal privacy; the bill does not set out a separate purpose statement. It is an introduced bill, not law.

  • Private entities possessing biometric identifiers would have to keep a written retention and destruction policy. They would have to destroy identifiers when the original purpose is met or within one year of a person’s last interaction, whichever comes first, subject to a valid court warrant.
  • For a “commercial purpose”—defined narrowly as marketing unrelated goods or services—the bill would require consent to collect or obtain a biometric identifier and would limit when an entity could disclose one.
  • Consent would not have to be affirmative: notice and a person’s silence or continued interaction could count.
  • Entities would have to protect identifiers using reasonable care for their industry and at least the same protections they use for other confidential and sensitive information.
  • The attorney general would have exclusive enforcement authority. The bill bars private lawsuits under these provisions or any other law for a violation of them.

What it means for you#

  • People whose biometric identifiers are held by private entities: The bill would require a retention policy and safeguards. But its consent and disclosure rules apply to commercial purposes, and consent could be inferred from inaction after notice.
  • Businesses and other private entities: The rules would apply to individuals and organizations, subject to broad exceptions. “Biometric identifier” includes certain measurements used to uniquely identify someone, such as a fingerprint or face-geometry scan, but excludes items such as photographs, medical images, and some health-care information.
  • People and entities in excluded settings: The bill would not apply to biometric identifiers collected or used in employment, or to financial institutions and their affiliates covered by the federal Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act. State and local agencies, courts, and government contractors working for those agencies are also excluded.
  • Entities using identifiers for security: The bill would not require notice or consent for collecting, using, or disclosing identifiers in furtherance of a “security purpose.” That term includes preventing shoplifting or fraud and protecting the security or integrity of software, accounts, online services, or any person.
  • Attorney general: The office would have exclusive authority to enforce the provisions. The bill does not set out a specific enforcement process or penalties.
  • Current law: The bill adds sections to Chapter 1, but the supplied material does not include current Missouri law on biometric identifiers, so what protections already exist could not be verified.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill assigns enforcement exclusively to the attorney general but does not provide a cost estimate, appropriation, or staffing requirement.
  • It does not set fees or fines.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define some key terms, including “reasonable standard of care” and “initial purpose.”
  • It gives no detailed rules for notice, how long a notice must be available, or how a person can challenge whether consent was given.
  • It does not specify how the attorney general would investigate or enforce violations, or what penalties could apply.
  • It is unclear how the biometric-identifier exclusions for some health-care information interact with the separate requirement that HIPAA-covered entities treat biometric identifiers as protected health information and unique health identifiers.
  • The supplied material does not show how these provisions would interact with existing Missouri laws.

Case for#

  • A written retention policy and a destruction deadline could limit how long private entities keep biometric identifiers.
  • The bill would require protections for stored and transmitted identifiers, including protections at least as strong as those used for other sensitive information.
  • Limits on commercial collection and disclosure could reduce the use of biometric identifiers for marketing unrelated to the original transaction.
  • Giving one state office exclusive enforcement authority could centralize enforcement.

Case against#

  • The bill’s consent rule allows silence or continued interaction to count, rather than requiring a clear affirmative choice.
  • The security-purpose exception is broad and removes notice and consent requirements for a wide range of collection, use, and disclosure.
  • The commercial-purpose rules cover a narrow category of marketing, while many settings and entities are exempt.
  • People could not bring a private lawsuit under these provisions or another law for a violation of them; the bill does not explain what enforcement remedies would be available.