Utility rates would require general rate cases

Summary#

S-1024, “My Power Bill Is Too High,” would amend North Carolina’s utility rate laws and provide money for a study. It would require electric utility rates to be set through general rate cases, barring automatic or preauthorized multiyear rate adjustments; its stated goal is to better protect customers. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • Electric utilities could not use automatic or preauthorized multiyear rate adjustments; rates would have to be established through a general rate case.
  • The bill would limit an approved performance-based regulation plan to 12 months. But other parts of its text still refer to multiyear plans and second- and third-year rate changes, so the intended rules are not fully clear.
  • The Utilities Commission would have to study whether performance incentives affect utility investment decisions, compare those incentives with returns on capital investments, assess options for changing incentive caps, and make recommendations. It must send the study to the Joint Legislative Energy Policy Commission by March 1, 2027.
  • The bill provides a one-time $10,000 General Fund appropriation to the Utilities Commission for the study.

What it means for you#

  • Electricity customers: The bill would change how utility rates are set, but it does not cap bills or guarantee lower rates. A general rate case can still result in a rate increase.
  • Electric utilities: They would have to use general rate cases to establish rates and could not use automatic or preauthorized multiyear adjustments. The bill does not specify how often a utility must file a case.
  • Utilities Commission: It would have to conduct and report the study. The bill does not set out a separate application, review, or appeal process for customers.
  • Taxpayers: The state would provide $10,000 for the study. The bill does not directly change taxes, utility benefits, or customer eligibility for a program.

Money#

The bill appropriates $10,000 in nonrecurring General Fund money for the Utilities Commission’s study.

  • No publicly available information gives an estimate of the Commission’s total study or staffing costs.
  • The bill does not estimate how changing rate-setting rules would affect utility costs or customer bills.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the current text of the amended laws, so the exact differences from current law could not be verified. The bill’s recitals say that 2021 legislation authorized multiyear rate plans and performance-based regulation.
  • The bill both bars multiyear rate adjustments and contains provisions referring to multiyear plans, including second- and third-year rate changes. It also changes the allowed plan period to 12 months. How these provisions would fit together is unclear.
  • The text retains a 1% limit on performance-incentive rewards and penalties, while requiring a study of whether such limits are effective. The available text does not make clear which parts of the existing performance-based rules would change.
  • The bill does not set a timetable or approval standard for general rate cases, or say how the Commission should act on the study’s recommendations.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that requiring a general rate case for rate changes would give the Commission a chance to examine them, rather than allowing automatic or preauthorized multiyear adjustments.
  • The required study could help lawmakers assess whether performance incentives meaningfully affect utility investment decisions and customer costs before deciding whether to change them.
  • The bill directs the study to consider customer affordability and avoiding unnecessary capital investments, issues its stated purpose says matter to customers.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not require lower bills or stronger performance incentives; it requires a study and leaves any later policy changes undecided.
  • General rate cases can still result in higher rates. The bill does not set a limit on rate increases through those cases.
  • The conflicting multiyear-plan language could make the rules difficult to interpret unless the text is clarified.
  • The $10,000 appropriation is specified, but the materials do not show whether it would cover the Commission’s full cost of the study.