Utility revenue limits, advisory committee created

Summary#

The enacted act, “Rocky Mount/Louisburg Utility Rev./Advisory,” amends North Carolina utility-revenue laws, repeals a 2021 law, and creates an advisory committee in Rocky Mount. Its stated goal is to limit certain uses of Rocky Mount and Louisburg utility revenues and give utility customers a formal way to advise the Rocky Mount City Council.

  • Rocky Mount must use electric and natural-gas rate revenue for each system’s operating costs, an allowed return on its investment, and—if revenue remains—lower rates and extra debt payments for system improvements. The Rocky Mount revenue restrictions expire January 1, 2029.
  • Louisburg must follow the new limits on electric-system revenue. The rules allow specified system costs and a capped return to the town; remaining revenue must go toward lower electric rates and extra debt payments for system improvements. The act also bars using electric-rate revenue for economic development projects.
  • Rocky Mount must establish a nine-member Public Utilities Advisory Committee on July 1, 2028. It will review and recommend on electric, natural-gas, water, and sewer services, but cannot set rates, control utility operations or funds, or hire or fire staff.
  • Rocky Mount’s committee must include five city residents and four outside-city customers: one residential and one commercial or industrial customer from each of Nash and Edgecombe counties. All voting members must be utility customers.

What it means for you#

  • Rocky Mount utility customers: The city must direct remaining electric and natural-gas revenue toward lower rates and extra debt payments for system improvements. The act does not guarantee when or by how much rates will fall.
  • Louisburg electric customers: The town must use remaining electric revenue for lower rates and extra debt payments for system improvements. Electric-rate revenue cannot be used for economic development projects.
  • Rocky Mount utility customers: Starting in 2028, the committee must review matters including proposed rates and fees, budgets, major construction contracts, utility extensions, financial reports, and proposed transfers of utility funds. It can make recommendations; the City Council keeps decision-making authority.
  • Rocky Mount City Council and staff: City staff must provide information reasonably needed by the committee, subject to confidentiality protections. The City Manager must send the proposed utility budget to the committee, which must make a written recommendation before the Council adopts the budget.
  • Taxpayers and municipal services: The act restricts certain transfers from utility funds, but does not prohibit transfers for listed operating costs, a permitted return, or reimbursement for costs reasonably allocable to a utility system.

Money#

The act sets rules for using utility revenue, but no cost estimate is provided.

  • The electric-system return transfer is capped at the greater of 3% of gross capital assets or 5% of gross annual revenue, based on the prior fiscal year’s audited statements.
  • Allowed operating costs include debt service, system improvements and equipment, reserves, rate-stabilization funds, payments in lieu of taxes, and reimbursement of reasonably allocable costs paid by other municipal funds.
  • Committee members serve without pay. The City Council may approve reimbursement of actual and necessary expenses.
  • City staff must provide committee information, but the act gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the prior version of the amended law or the repealed 2021 law. The exact change from existing law, and what the repeal removes, could not be verified.
  • The electric-revenue provision is amended twice in the act, with separate applicability and timing provisions for Rocky Mount and Louisburg. The supplied text does not explain how those amendments are meant to fit together.
  • The act does not specify how lower rates must be calculated or when customers would see any reduction.
  • It does not set a process for customers to bring concerns to the committee, or require the City Council to accept its recommendations.
  • The act does not estimate the cost of staff support or expense reimbursements.

Case for#

  • The revenue rules could help ensure that utility charges support utility systems, rather than being transferred for unrelated municipal purposes.
  • Allowing specified costs, reserves, and a capped return recognizes that utilities can have costs beyond day-to-day operations.
  • The committee gives city and outside-city customers a defined role in reviewing utility budgets, rates, and plans.
  • The committee’s advisory status leaves final decisions with the elected City Council.

Case against#

  • The revenue limits may reduce the town’s flexibility to use utility funds for other municipal needs, even though the act permits certain costs and transfers.
  • The act directs remaining revenue toward lower rates and extra debt payments but does not explain how those uses will be balanced or when rate changes would occur.
  • The committee cannot make binding decisions, and the City Council is not required to follow its recommendations.
  • It is unclear how the temporary Rocky Mount rules interact with the separate Louisburg amendment to the same electric-revenue law.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1713660

    Passed47 members voted

    Motion 9 To Concur

    FOR · 29AGAINST · 18

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    29For

    • Republican29

    18Against

    • Democratic18

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1699906

    Passed48 members voted

    Second Reading

    FOR · 30AGAINST · 18

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    30For

    • Republican30

    18Against

    • Democratic18

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.