Brand Owners Open Spirits Stores Nearby

Summary#

Bill 116, the Liquor Statute Amendment Act (Sale of Spirits Manufactured for Brand Owners), 2017, would amend the Liquor Control Act and the Alcohol and Gaming Regulation and Public Protection Act, 1996. Its stated goal is to allow brand owners who contract for spirits to be made in Ontario to be authorized to sell those spirits in a store near the manufacturing site.

  • The Liquor Control Act would allow brand owners to be authorized to operate a store selling their spirits to the public, if the store is within 500 metres of the manufacturer’s premises. The bill does not grant automatic permission.
  • For the purposes of the other Act’s tax rules, a qualifying store would be a “distillery retail store” if it is owned and operated by the brand owner and the brand owner is authorized to sell spirits there.
  • The bill does not change the stated powers of existing manufacturer-run stores, or set a tax rate or require any person to open a store.

What it means for you#

  • Brand owners: If authorized, a person who owns a brand and contracts with a manufacturer to make its spirits in Ontario could operate a store selling those spirits to the public. The store must be within 500 metres of the manufacturing premises.
  • Spirits manufacturers: The bill would not require manufacturers to make contracts with brand owners or open stores. A brand owner’s store would have to be near the manufacturer’s premises.
  • People buying spirits: The bill could create another place to buy spirits from a brand owner, but only if the brand owner is authorized and operates a qualifying store.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill does not directly change taxes, create a public service, or require public spending in the text provided.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill changes a definition used for the tax rules on beer, wine and spirits, but does not state a tax-rate change or the tax effect.
  • It does not specify public spending, fees, staffing, or costs for businesses.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say who would decide whether to authorize a brand owner, or what criteria would apply.
  • It does not set application steps, timelines, operating conditions, appeals, or reporting requirements.
  • It does not define the terms “brand” or “contracts with a manufacturer.”
  • The material does not explain the tax treatment that would follow from classifying a brand owner’s store as a “distillery retail store.”
  • The supplied material does not say whether the bill received Royal Assent. As drafted, it would take effect on Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would let brand owners sell spirits made for their brands in Ontario, rather than limiting this kind of nearby store to spirits manufacturers.
  • The 500-metre limit ties the store to the place where the spirits are made.
  • The bill would create this option without requiring a brand owner to open a store or a manufacturer to enter a contract.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not explain how authorization decisions would be made or what safeguards would apply.
  • The 500-metre limit may restrict where a brand owner can operate, but the bill does not explain why that distance was chosen.
  • The bill does not spell out the tax consequences or the costs of setting up and administering authorizations.