Innocent Insurance Recovery Act

Summary#

Bill 125, the Innocent Persons Insurance Recovery Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Insurance Act. Its stated goal is to limit when an insurance contract can use another person’s criminal or intentional act to deny a property-loss claim. The supplied material does not say whether the bill passed; if enacted, it would take effect on Royal Assent.

  • An exclusion for property loss caused by a criminal or intentional act or omission would apply only to claims by people who caused the loss, helped or colluded in causing it, consented while knowing or having reason to know it would cause the loss, or belong to a class set by regulation.
  • A person protected by this change could recover no more than their proportionate interest in the lost or damaged property.
  • Regulations could set additional classes of people who are subject to the exclusion and requirements that a person must meet to claim the protection.

What it means for you#

  • People with an insured interest in damaged property: The specified exclusion could not be used against your claim just because another person caused the loss. This does not guarantee payment: other policy terms may still affect coverage, and your recovery could not exceed your proportionate interest.
  • People who caused or helped cause the loss: The exclusion could still apply to your claim. It could also apply if you consented and knew, or should have known, the act would cause the loss, or if regulations place you in an excluded class.
  • Insurers: The change could require payment on some claims that the specified exclusion would otherwise block, subject to the policy’s other terms and the bill’s limits.
  • Government: Regulations could define excluded classes and claim requirements. The bill does not set those details itself.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not set a tax, fee, fine, or public spending amount.
  • It could increase insurer payments on some claims, but the material does not estimate the effect on insurers or premiums.

What is unclear#

  • The current Insurance Act was not supplied, so the existing law and the full change from it could not be verified.
  • The bill does not say which classes will be prescribed or what requirements a claimant must meet.
  • It does not set claim procedures, timelines, or appeal rights.
  • The bill refers to regulations but the available material does not say when they would be made or what they would contain. No publicly available information on the bill’s passage status is included in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to stop one person’s criminal or intentional conduct from automatically defeating another person’s claim to their insured share of property.
  • Limiting recovery to a person’s proportionate interest could protect an innocent co-owner without allowing them to claim the value of someone else’s share.
  • Allowing regulations to set requirements and excluded classes could let the rules address circumstances not detailed in the bill.

Case against#

  • The protection depends in part on future regulations. Until the classes and requirements are known, it is hard to tell who would qualify or be excluded.
  • The bill only limits one kind of policy exclusion; other terms could still prevent or limit payment. It does not create a guarantee of coverage.
  • If insurers must pay claims they could otherwise deny, costs could rise, but the bill provides no estimate of the effect on insurers or premiums.