Construction lien reform speeds payments

Summary#

Bill 142, the Construction Lien Amendment Act, 2017, was enacted as Chapter 24 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes. It amends the Construction Lien Act, renaming it the Construction Act and changing payment, dispute, lien and bond rules. Its stated goal was to respond to an expert review of Ontario’s construction lien law; that goal is not a guaranteed result.

  • Owners must generally pay a contractor’s proper invoice within 28 days. Contractors and subcontractors must generally pass payments down the chain within seven days, subject to rules for disputes and holdbacks. Late amounts accrue interest.
  • A new interim adjudication process lets parties to contracts and subcontracts take specified construction disputes to an adjudicator. The decision is binding for now, but the matter can later be decided by a court, an arbitrator or written agreement.
  • Contractors on qualifying public contracts must provide labour-and-material payment bonds and performance bonds. The required contract-price threshold is left to regulations; the bill sets a minimum bond limit of 50% unless regulations set another percentage.
  • The bill adds rules for handling trust funds and limits when trust funds can be used to set off other debts. It also changes lien deadlines, including extending key preservation periods from 45 to 60 days and the time to perfect a lien from 45 to 90 days.
  • A lien would no longer attach to a municipality’s interest in any premises it owns, not just a public street or highway. The lien instead becomes a charge under the Act.
  • The law was enacted, but many substantive changes were set to start only on proclamation. The supplied material does not say when they started.

What it means for you#

  • Owners, contractors and subcontractors: The bill sets payment deadlines and a route to dispute some payment issues. A payer can withhold disputed amounts by giving the required notice and reasons. Holdback rules still apply.
  • Contractors on qualifying public contracts: You must provide both required bonds when entering the contract, unless an exception applies. Architects and engineers acting as contractors are excluded from this bond requirement.
  • Construction workers and suppliers: The payment rules do not reduce contractors’ or subcontractors’ duties to pay wages. A labour-and-material bond may provide a right to claim against the bond’s surety (the party that guarantees payment) if the principal defaults, subject to the bond’s terms.
  • Municipalities and people supplying work or materials on municipal property: A lien will not attach to the municipality’s property interest. The Act provides for a charge instead; the bill does not remove all security for payment.
  • Condominium owners and corporations: A person preserving a lien for work on common elements must notify the corporation and specified unit or land owners. An individual owner may ask a court to address the share of a lien attributed to that owner’s common interest.
  • General public: The bill does not create a general tax, rebate or direct public benefit.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Contractors on qualifying public contracts must pay for the required bonds; the bill gives no estimate of that cost.
  • An adjudication authority must train and qualify adjudicators, keep a public registry and appoint adjudicators when needed. It may charge fees, subject to regulations. The bill gives no staffing or operating-cost estimate.
  • Parties pay adjudication fees, generally split equally unless the adjudicator decides otherwise. No fee amounts are provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves key details to regulations, including which public contracts require bonds, holdback payment thresholds, forms and some adjudication procedures.
  • The material does not give proclamation dates for the substantive changes, so it does not establish when each one took effect.
  • The bill does not specify the adjudication authority, its actual fees, or its staffing and funding.
  • The parent Act was not supplied. The explanatory note describes some changes from prior law, but I could not verify the full current law or how every amendment interacts with it.
  • The bill sets deadlines and notice requirements, but many practical details depend on regulations or procedures not included here.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address slow payment and construction disputes. Firm payment deadlines and a quick interim decision process could help parties resolve cash-flow disputes sooner.
  • Trust-account and record-keeping rules could make it easier to trace construction funds.
  • Required payment and performance bonds on qualifying public contracts could offer an added source of protection when payment or performance fails.
  • Longer lien deadlines could give claimants more time to preserve and perfect their claims.

Case against#

  • A short adjudication process can produce a binding decision before a dispute is fully resolved in court or arbitration. That may bring speed, but it may also leave a party facing payment before the final outcome.
  • Bond requirements and adjudication fees add costs. The bill gives no estimates, and the public-contract threshold is left to regulations.
  • The bill gives the adjudication authority significant duties, while its appointment, fees and procedures depend on later decisions or regulations.
  • Removing a lien from municipal property changes the security available to claimants. The bill provides a charge instead, but the supplied material does not explain how that may affect recovery in practice.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017120501

    Passed87 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 142

    FOR · 87

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    87For

    • Liberal48
    • PC25
    • NDP13
    • Independent1

    0Against

  2. Division No. 2017100401

    Passed91 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 142

    FOR · 52AGAINST · 39

    52For

    • Liberal51
    • Independent1

    39Against

    • PC27
    • NDP12
  3. Division No. 2017100402

    Passed92 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 142

    FOR · 92

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    92For

    • Liberal51
    • PC27
    • NDP13
    • Independent1

    0Against