Organic labeling rules require certification

Summary#

Bill 153, the Organic Products Act, 2017, would create a new Ontario law. It would prohibit marketing or labelling a product as “organic” unless it is certified under the Act. Its stated goal is to regulate organic-product labelling and certification.

  • The Minister responsible for the Act could set certification rules by regulation and designate certification bodies. The Minister could also make agreements with those bodies.
  • The Minister must establish a public register of certified products. If the Minister makes an agreement with a certification body, that body would establish the register; the Minister must maintain it and publish it on an Ontario government website.
  • Inspectors could enter and inspect places where products are believed to be marketed as organic, take samples, and require relevant records. Warrants are generally required to enter a dwelling or search and seize, with an exception for urgent circumstances.
  • The bill would allow offences to be punished by fines and, for individuals, possible jail time. It would also allow administrative penalties, with amounts set by future regulations.
  • The Minister could make regulations that require fees for matters such as inspections, testing, storage, seizure or disposal. The bill says it does not affect the Farm Products Marketing Act or the Milk Act.

What it means for you#

  • Businesses and people marketing products: You could not market or label a product using “organic,” “biologique,” or another term later prescribed by regulation unless it has been certified under the Act. “Marketing” includes preparation, advertising, buying and selling. The bill covers goods such as food, drink, cosmetics and textiles derived from plants or animals, as well as other products that may be prescribed.
  • Businesses and people seeking certification: The bill allows regulations to set application steps, certification standards, how long certification lasts, renewals, suspensions, cancellations and appeals. Those rules are not set out in the bill.
  • People buying products: A public register would list certified products and any other information required by regulation. The bill does not create a direct consumer benefit, such as a new right to compensation.
  • People and businesses subject to inspection: Inspectors could take samples without charge, examine or copy relevant records, and require reasonable assistance and information. Obstructing an inspector or giving false or misleading information would be an offence.
  • Taxpayers and product owners: The bill would give the government enforcement and administrative duties. It does not set a budget. It could also allow fees to be charged under future regulations.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Minister may appoint inspectors and must appoint a Registrar to administer administrative penalties. The bill gives no staffing numbers or cost estimate.
  • Future regulations could set fees, including for inspections, testing, storage, seizure and disposal. The bill sets no fee amounts.
  • Maximum court fines would be $20,000 for an individual’s first offence and $30,000 for later offences; an individual could also face up to six months in jail. For a corporation, maximum fines would be $50,000 and $75,000. Administrative penalty amounts would be set by regulation.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not itself set certification standards or say how certification bodies would assess products. These details are left to regulations.
  • It does not set application timelines, review steps, appeal procedures, or rules for how decisions must be made.
  • It is unclear what fees would be charged, how much administrative penalties would be, and how many staff or resources enforcement would need.
  • The supplied material does not explain how this law would interact with other existing organic certification or labelling rules. It does say the Farm Products Marketing Act and Milk Act would remain unaffected.
  • No start date is provided beyond six months after Royal Assent. Whether the bill becomes law is not stated in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make “organic” claims depend on certification under a common provincial law. That could give businesses and buyers a shared basis for the claim.
  • A public register could help people check which products have been certified.
  • Inspection powers, penalties and rules for suspending or cancelling certification could support compliance with the certification system.
  • Allowing regulations to set standards could let the government specify details that the bill itself does not provide.

Case against#

  • The bill sets the restriction before setting the standards that determine what certification requires. Businesses would need later regulations to know the full rules.
  • The Minister would have broad authority to set important rules, designate certification bodies and create exemptions. The bill does not specify limits or safeguards for many of these choices.
  • Inspections and possible fees could add costs for businesses. The bill does not estimate those costs or say who would pay in each case.
  • Administrative penalties could apply even if a person took reasonable steps to prevent a violation or honestly believed mistaken facts. The bill leaves the amounts and detailed rules to future regulations.