Summary#
Bill 59, the Organic Products Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to regulate how organic products are certified and labelled. The text says the Act would start six months after Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not say whether it received Royal Assent.
- A person could not market or label a product as “organic,” “biologique,” or another term later prescribed by regulation unless it was certified under the Act.
- The Minister could make certification rules and designate certification bodies. The Minister could also make agreements with those bodies about certification.
- The Minister, or a certification body under an agreement, would have to establish a register of certified products. The Minister would have to maintain and publish it on an Ontario government website.
- The Minister could appoint inspectors. They could inspect places and vehicles where they have reasonable grounds to believe products are labelled, marketed, or intended to be marketed as organic; take free samples; and require relevant records and information.
- The bill would allow criminal fines and imprisonment, as well as administrative penalties. Many details—including certification standards and administrative-penalty amounts—would be left to regulations.
What it means for you#
- Businesses and people selling products: You could not market or label a product using the covered organic terms unless it had been certified under the Act. The bill does not prohibit selling a product that is not certified if it is not marketed or labelled using those terms.
- People seeking certification: The Act itself does not set the certification criteria or application process. Those details could be set by regulations, and the Minister could designate knowledgeable people or bodies as certification bodies.
- Consumers: The Minister would have to publish a register listing certified products. The bill does not set out how quickly the register must be updated.
- Businesses and others subject to inspection: Inspectors could require assistance and relevant information. They could enter a dwelling only with the occupier’s consent or a warrant; other entry and search powers have conditions, including warrant requirements and an exception for urgent circumstances.
- People and corporations found in breach: An individual could face a fine of up to $20,000 for a first offence or $30,000 for a later offence, up to six months in jail, or both. A corporation could face fines of up to $50,000 or $75,000. A director or officer who authorized, permitted, or agreed to the offence could also be guilty.
- Taxpayers and regulated businesses: The bill would give the government inspection, register, and enforcement duties and powers, but does not specify staffing or operating arrangements.
Money#
No cost estimate is in the available material.
- The bill permits regulations to set fees, including for inspections, sampling, testing, storage, removal, disposal, and return of products or other things. It does not set fee amounts.
- Regulations could make some fees payable jointly and individually by the place’s owner or occupier and by the person who had possession, care, or control of the relevant place or item.
- Administrative-penalty amounts would be set by regulation. The bill allows penalties for each day or part of a day a contravention occurs or continues.
- No estimate is given for government costs, fees, or penalties collected.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define the standards a product must meet to be “organic.” It leaves certification criteria, procedures, and the treatment of multi-ingredient products to regulations.
- The bill does not set out application, inspection, decision, or appeal procedures. It allows regulations to address applications and appeals.
- The bill does not specify certification-body fees, administrative-penalty amounts, or most other fees.
- The text does not explain how the new rules would interact with other organic-certification systems. It says the Act would not affect the Farm Products Marketing Act or the Milk Act.
- The supplied material does not state the bill’s current status or whether regulations have been made.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make organic claims depend on certification rather than a seller’s claim alone.
- A public register could help people check which products are certified.
- Inspection and enforcement powers could help detect and address false organic claims.
- Allowing the Minister to set detailed standards by regulation could let the rules address different products, including multi-ingredient products.
Case against#
- The bill makes certification necessary for organic claims but leaves the core standards and many practical rules to future regulations. The bill alone does not show what certification would require.
- Inspection and record-access powers are broad. Although the bill sets limits for entry into dwellings and provides for warrants, it does not detail all inspection procedures.
- Administrative penalties can apply even if a person took reasonable steps to prevent a contravention or honestly believed mistaken facts. The bill does not itself set penalty amounts or describe an appeal process for these orders.
- Certification and possible fees could add costs for people and businesses making organic claims; the amounts and likely effects are not given.