New organic-labeling rules require certification

Summary#

Bill 54 would create a new Ontario law, the Organic Products Act, 2018; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated aim is to regulate organic-product certification and labelling. If enacted, it would start six months after Royal Assent.

  • A person could not market or label a product as “organic,” “biologique,” or another term set by regulation unless it had been certified under the Act.
  • The Minister may make rules for certification, including standards, applications, certification periods, renewals, suspensions, cancellations and appeals. The bill itself does not set the certification standards.
  • The Minister may appoint inspectors, who could inspect relevant places and vehicles, take samples, and require relevant records and information. Entry into a dwelling generally requires consent or a warrant.
  • The Minister, or a certification body if the Minister has an agreement with it, would establish a register of certified products. The Minister must maintain and publish the register online.
  • The bill creates offences and administrative penalties. It also allows regulations to set fees and many other rules, including rules on inspections, product standards and exemptions.

What it means for you#

  • Businesses and people marketing products: They would have to meet the certification requirement before using the covered organic terms in marketing or on labels. “Marketing” includes preparing, advertising, buying and selling products. The bill does not itself require every producer to apply for certification.
  • Consumers: The register would let the public look up products listed as certified. The bill does not guarantee a particular product’s quality beyond certification under the rules made for the Act.
  • Certification bodies: The Minister may designate bodies and may make an agreement with one about certification. A designated body would have to provide information when the Minister requires it.
  • Inspectors and the Minister: Inspectors may be appointed; the bill does not require a particular number. Inspectors could seize items under a warrant, or without one in exigent circumstances (urgent situations where getting a warrant is impractical).
  • People or businesses found in breach: Individuals could face a fine of up to $20,000 for a first offence or $30,000 for a later offence, up to six months in jail, or both. Corporations could face fines of up to $50,000 or $75,000. Administrative penalties may also apply; their amounts depend on regulations. Paying one and correcting the breach prevents conviction for the same breach.
  • Current-law comparison: The supplied material does not include existing Ontario laws on organic-product claims, so what would change from current law cannot be verified. The bill says it does not affect the Farm Products Marketing Act or the Milk Act.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill authorizes the Minister to appoint inspectors and requires the Minister to maintain and publish the register, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Regulations may set fees for matters such as inspections, testing, storage and seizure. The bill does not set fee amounts.
  • The bill allows fines and administrative penalties, but does not estimate revenue or the cost of enforcement.

What is unclear#

  • What standards products must meet to be certified, which certification bodies would be designated, and what application and appeal processes would apply.
  • Whether and when the Minister would make the regulations needed to operate the certification system, and whether exemptions would be made.
  • How administrative penalties would be calculated. The bill leaves their amounts to regulations.
  • How the register would be governed and what additional information it would include.
  • The supplied material does not state the bill’s status or provide a current-law comparison. No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that requiring certification before organic claims are used could give buyers a way to distinguish certified products from products making unsupported claims.
  • A public register could help buyers, businesses and government check which products are certified.
  • Inspection powers, penalties and rules on labels and standards could help enforce the certification requirement.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves key parts of the system—especially certification standards, fees and penalty amounts—to future regulations. The Act itself does not say what a product must meet to qualify as organic.
  • Broad inspection and information-gathering powers could place demands on businesses and people handling products. The bill does not estimate those costs.
  • An administrative penalty can apply even if a person took all reasonable steps to prevent a breach or honestly and reasonably believed mistaken facts. The bill does not set the penalty amounts.
  • The bill does not specify when regulations would be made or how quickly the certification and register systems would be ready.