Life settlements trading under new rules

Summary#

Bill 162, the Insurance Amendment Act (Life Settlements), 2017, would amend Ontario’s Insurance Act. It would create a conditional exception to the Act’s restriction on trading in life insurance policies; its stated goal is consumer protection.

  • A policy could be sold under the exception only if it has been held for at least 36 months by the original policyholder, alone or with a related person as defined in federal tax law.
  • The buyer would have to meet requirements set by regulation, and the sale agreement would have to follow a prescribed form and process.
  • The policyholder(s) covered by the ownership condition could cancel the sale agreement without giving a reason during the 10 days after signing.
  • The Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO), an existing commission, would have to oversee these transactions under rules set by regulation.
  • The restriction on trading in policies would continue to apply outside this exception.

What it means for you#

  • Eligible policyholders: You could sell a qualifying policy if the buyer and agreement meet the rules set by regulation. The bill does not guarantee that a buyer will be available or set a sale price.
  • Policyholders and related persons: You could cancel a qualifying sale agreement without giving a reason within the 10-day period.
  • Potential buyers: You would have to meet prescribed requirements and follow the prescribed agreement process.
  • FSCO: It would have a legal duty to oversee these transactions under regulations.
  • Others: The bill does not directly change insurance coverage, premiums, taxes, or benefits.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • FSCO would have to provide oversight, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The bill does not set fees or fines. It leaves buyer requirements and some transaction rules to regulations; costs of meeting those rules are unknown.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say what buyer requirements or other transaction conditions will be prescribed.
  • It does not provide the required agreement form or explain how agreements must be presented.
  • It does not set out how FSCO’s oversight will work, or what powers or remedies it will use.
  • It does not state when it would come into force; that date would be set by proclamation.
  • The supplied materials do not include the Insurance Act, so the existing law and how this exception would fit with it could not be independently verified.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let some policyholders sell a policy while keeping the existing restriction in place for transactions outside the exception.
  • A 10-day, no-reason cancellation period gives the covered policyholder(s) time to reconsider a sale.
  • Requiring FSCO oversight could provide a way to protect consumers as life-settlement transactions take place.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves key protections to future regulations, so its requirements cannot be assessed from the bill text alone.
  • The bill requires oversight but does not spell out how FSCO would carry it out or what happens if a transaction does not meet the rules.
  • The exception would not cover policies held for less than 36 months, or sales that fail the prescribed conditions. The bill does not explain why those limits were chosen.