Summary#
Bill 219, the Life Settlements and Loans Act, 2020, would amend Ontario’s Insurance Act. Its stated goal is to let policyholders access value from life insurance policies through sales, loans secured by policies, or donations.
- It would create an exception to the Act’s prohibition on trading in life insurance policies, but only if the policy has been held for at least 24 months and the recipient is allowed by regulation.
- An original policyholder or a person to whom the policy was validly transferred could sell or assign it, use it as collateral security, or donate it to a registered charity.
- The agreement must be presented with “full, true, and plain disclosure.” The policyholder or transferee could cancel it for any reason within 10 days after entering a binding agreement.
- The Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) would have to oversee these transactions under rules set by regulation.
- If the conditions are met, the policy would not be subject to a competing claim under any other Act. The bill would start on a date set by proclamation.
What it means for you#
- Policyholders and transferees: You could enter one of the listed transactions if the conditions are met. The bill does not require anyone to offer you a sale, loan, or donation arrangement.
- People or entities taking a policy: You would have to be prescribed by regulation to receive a policy through a sale, assignment, collateral security, or donation.
- Registered charities: A policy could be donated to a charity registered under Canada’s Income Tax Act, subject to the bill’s other conditions.
- FSRA: It would have a duty to oversee the transactions under rules made by regulation. The bill does not set out a specific application or approval process.
- People with claims against a policyholder or policy: The bill says a policy meeting the conditions would not be subject to a competing claim under another Act. How this would affect particular claims is not explained.
- Other policyholders and the public: The bill does not itself create a loan program, set prices, or guarantee that a policyholder will receive a particular amount.
Money#
No publicly available information.
- The bill requires FSRA oversight, but gives no estimate of the cost or staffing needed.
- It sets no fees, payments, or loan amounts. The financial terms of any transaction are not specified.
What is unclear#
- The regulations that would name eligible recipients and govern FSRA’s oversight are not included.
- The bill does not explain how disclosure would be checked or what happens if it is inadequate.
- It does not set out enforcement powers, complaint steps, or how disputes would be resolved.
- It does not explain how the competing-claim rule would interact with specific claims under other Acts.
- The bill’s text does not describe tax treatment for a sale, loan, or donation.
Case for#
- The bill’s stated aim is to give policyholders another way to access value from a policy instead of relying only on surrendering it to an insurer.
- A possible argument for the bill is that policyholders could choose among more options, while the 24-month holding condition and 10-day cancellation period provide some limits and protection.
- Required disclosure and FSRA oversight could help protect people entering these transactions, depending on the regulations.
Case against#
- The bill leaves key protections to regulations that are not included, so it is unclear who could receive policies and what oversight would require.
- The 10-day cancellation period and disclosure requirement may not be enough to protect policyholders; the bill does not explain how disclosure or compliance would be enforced.
- Giving qualifying policies priority over competing claims under any other Act could affect people or entities with claims against those policies. The bill does not explain how that rule would work in specific cases.
- FSRA must oversee the transactions, but the bill provides no cost estimate or details about the resources needed.