Bill allows life-insurance loans.

Summary#

Bill 20, the Insurance Amendment Act (Life Loans), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Insurance Act. Its stated goal is to allow certain life-insurance assignments for loans while providing consumer protection; the bill does not require anyone to offer or take a loan.

  • It would create an exception to the Act’s restriction on people other than insurers or their authorized agents trading in life-insurance policies.
  • The exception would apply to a policy held by its original policyholder (alone or with a related person) or donated to a registered charity. The 36-month holding rule applies to the original-policyholder route, not the charity route.
  • The person or entity receiving the assignment must lend against the policy to the original policyholder, meet requirements set by regulation, and use the required form and manner for the agreement.
  • The Financial Services Commission of Ontario (the “Commission” in the bill) must oversee these transactions under rules set by regulation.
  • An original policyholder, or the original policyholder and related person, could cancel the assignment agreement without giving a reason within 10 days after entering a binding agreement.

What it means for you#

  • Life-insurance policyholders: If the conditions are met, you could assign a policy in exchange for a loan secured against it. The bill does not make lenders offer loans or set loan terms.
  • Policyholders using the original-holder route: The policy must have been held for at least 36 months from its issue date. The bill gives the specified policyholder or policyholders 10 days to cancel the assignment agreement.
  • Registered charities: A donated policy is included in the exception, without the 36-month condition stated for policies held by the original policyholder. The bill does not set out how this route would work in practice.
  • Lenders and other entities receiving an assignment: They would have to meet regulatory requirements and follow the required format and method for presenting the agreement.
  • People with other policies or transactions: The exception would not apply unless all the bill’s conditions are met. The bill does not directly change insurance benefits, premiums, or taxes.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires Commission oversight, but gives no estimate for staffing or other costs.
  • It does not set a fee, fine, loan amount, or public funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves key requirements, including the lender’s qualifications and the agreement’s form, to regulations that are not supplied.
  • It does not give details on how the Commission’s oversight would work, or what steps a consumer or lender would follow.
  • The bill’s cooling-off right applies to the assignment agreement; it does not explain how cancellation would affect any separate loan agreement.
  • The supplied explanatory note describes the current restriction, but the Insurance Act itself was not supplied. I could not independently verify the current rule or how this exception would interact with other existing rules.
  • The bill would start on a date set by proclamation; no start date is given.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would let some policyholders borrow against a life-insurance policy through a defined exception to the restriction on trading in policies.
  • The 36-month condition for policies held by the original policyholder could limit the exception to policies that have been held for a period of time.
  • A 10-day cancellation period and required Commission oversight are intended as consumer protections.
  • Requiring lenders to meet rules and present agreements in a set manner could support consistent safeguards, though the details are left to regulations.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves important protections to future regulations, so its practical safeguards cannot be judged from the bill text alone.
  • It does not set out how oversight would work or what consumers could do if a lender failed to meet the requirements.
  • The 10-day cancellation right is for the assignment agreement. The bill does not clearly explain its effect on a separate loan agreement.
  • The exception would permit assignments in specified cases, but the bill does not explain what policy rights the borrower or lender would have after assignment.