Summary#
Bill 171, the Phones Down, Heads Up Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. Its stated goal is to raise awareness of distracted driving and reduce pedestrian use of devices while crossing roads; these are aims, not guaranteed results.
- The Ministry of Transportation would have to run an annual campaign about distracted driving, with an emphasis on texting and driving.
- Pedestrians would be prohibited from crossing a roadway while holding and using a wireless communication device, an electronic entertainment device, or another device set by regulation.
- The bill lists two exceptions: using the device to contact emergency services, or continuing a phone call started before crossing.
- A conviction would carry a fine of $50 for a first offence, $75 for a second, and $125 for later offences.
- A municipal council could opt out of the pedestrian-device rule by passing a by-law.
What it means for you#
- Pedestrians: If the rule applied where you cross, holding and using a covered device while crossing could lead to a fine, unless one of the listed exceptions applied. A municipality could opt out.
- Municipalities: Councils could choose to opt out by by-law; the bill would not require them to do so.
- Drivers and the public: The Ministry would have to run the annual awareness campaign. The bill itself would not add a driver offence.
- Current law: The supplied material does not include the existing Highway Traffic Act, so I could not verify how the bill’s provisions compare with current law.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided.
- The Ministry would have to run an annual campaign, but the bill gives no budget or staffing estimate.
- The bill sets fines for pedestrian offences, but the supplied material does not say who would collect or keep the money.
What is unclear#
- “Wireless communication device” and “electronic entertainment device” are not defined in the supplied text. The bill would let regulations add other covered devices.
- The bill does not explain how the device rule would be enforced or how prior offences would be counted for higher fines.
- It does not explain when a municipal opt-out by-law would take effect or how people would be told the rule no longer applied.
- The supplied material does not say whether the bill passed. No publicly available information.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address distraction while pedestrians cross roadways, when attention to the crossing may matter.
- A possible argument for the annual campaign is that it would give the Ministry an ongoing way to raise awareness of distracted driving, especially texting and driving.
- Letting municipalities opt out would allow local councils to decide whether the pedestrian-device rule should apply in their municipality.
Case against#
- The bill does not define its main device terms, and regulations could add more devices. People may not know exactly what is covered.
- The fines would apply to pedestrians, but the bill does not set out enforcement details or how repeat offences would be tracked.
- The annual campaign is mandatory, but the bill gives no cost estimate or detail about what the campaign must include.
- Because municipalities could opt out, the pedestrian rule might not apply everywhere in Ontario.