Summary#
Bill 11, the Phones Down, Heads Up Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. Its stated goal is to raise awareness of distracted driving and reduce pedestrians’ use of certain devices while crossing a roadway.
- Pedestrians could not cross a roadway while holding and using a wireless communication device, an electronic entertainment device, or another device prescribed under the Act.
- Exceptions would allow a pedestrian to use a device to contact ambulance, police or fire emergency services, or to continue a phone call begun before crossing.
- A municipality’s council could opt out of the pedestrian rule by passing a by-law.
- The Ministry of Transportation would have to run an annual campaign about the dangers of distracted driving, with an emphasis on texting and driving.
- A pedestrian convicted of breaking the rule would face a fine of $50 for a first offence, $75 for a second, and $125 for each later offence.
What it means for you#
- Pedestrians: In municipalities that have not opted out, you could be fined if convicted of holding and using a covered device while crossing a roadway, unless one of the stated exceptions applies.
- Municipalities: Councils could choose whether the pedestrian rule applies locally by passing an opt-out by-law. The bill does not require them to opt out.
- Ministry of Transportation: The Ministry would have to conduct an annual awareness campaign. The bill does not set its format or specific content beyond its focus on distracted-driving dangers and texting and driving.
- Everyone else: The bill does not directly change rules for drivers, create a new public service, or change taxes or benefits.
- The available material does not include the current Highway Traffic Act, so I could not verify what rules already apply.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- The Ministry would have to run the annual campaign, but the bill gives no staffing or spending estimate.
- The bill sets fines for convictions, but the material does not estimate how much fine revenue would be collected.
- No cost estimate is given for municipalities that consider or pass an opt-out by-law.
What is unclear#
- The bill would allow rules to prescribe other devices covered by the ban, but the supplied material does not say which devices would be prescribed.
- It does not set a process for deciding whether someone broke the rule, beyond making a contravention an offence punishable on conviction.
- It does not say how the campaign would be delivered or how its effect would be assessed.
- The bill would take effect three months after Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not state whether or when it received Royal Assent.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address the risk of distraction while pedestrians cross roadways.
- A possible argument for the rule is that it sets a clear limit on device use at a time when pedestrians need to pay attention.
- The emergency and ongoing-call exceptions preserve some device use, while the municipal opt-out gives councils a choice about applying the rule locally.
- An annual campaign would make distracted-driving awareness a continuing Ministry duty, rather than a one-time effort.
Case against#
- The bill leaves municipalities free to opt out, so the pedestrian rule might not apply everywhere in Ontario.
- The bill does not specify which additional devices may be prescribed, leaving an important part of the ban to later decisions.
- The Ministry’s annual campaign is required, but the bill sets no minimum budget, content, or way to measure its results.
- The bill sets fines but the supplied material does not explain how enforcement would work in practice.