Stronger, Fairer Budget Measures Act

Summary#

Bill 177, the Stronger, Fairer Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2017, both amends many existing Ontario laws and enacts new ones. It was enacted as Chapter 34 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes; some provisions were set to start later or by proclamation. Its stated goal is to implement budget measures and other legal changes—not to guarantee any particular result.

  • It creates a $85-million trust for cleanup of contaminants in the English and Wabigoon Rivers. A panel with representatives appointed by Grassy Narrows First Nation and Wabaseemoong Independent Nations directs payments, subject to the trust’s terms and payment criteria.
  • It authorizes building-condition evaluation programs for buildings later prescribed by regulation. For buildings covered by a program, owners must maintain and operate them in line with the law and ensure evaluations take place.
  • It creates a legal system for the Minister of Transportation to designate high-occupancy toll (HOT) lanes on parts of provincial highways. The Minister may set tolls; using a lane outside its rules is an offence.
  • It changes pension rules, including creating a registry to help missing pension beneficiaries find benefits and allowing certain multi-employer plans to convert defined benefits to target benefits, with notice, consultation and the Superintendent’s advance consent.
  • It creates legal structures for Indigenous post-secondary institutes and the Centre Jules-Léger schools, and establishes the Université de l’Ontario français. Funding for Indigenous institutes is not automatic: the Minister may prescribe which institutes receive ongoing operating funding.
  • It changes rules in areas including workplace mental-stress benefits, taxes, insurance regulation, provincial-offence cases and annual reports by provincial agencies.

What it means for you#

  • Building owners: If your building is prescribed for an evaluation program, you must arrange evaluations and keep required records. An inspector may enter at a reasonable time without a warrant to inspect buildings for compliance, subject to the Act’s limits on entry into a dwelling. The bill does not itself say which buildings will be covered or how often they must be evaluated.
  • Drivers: If the Minister designates a HOT lane, regulations will set who may use it and on what terms. The person named on the vehicle permit, or the person registered to a toll device, may have to pay the toll. The fine for breaking HOT-lane rules is $60 to $500. After a toll notice, failure to pay within 90 days can lead to refusal to validate or issue a vehicle permit—even while a dispute or appeal is underway.
  • Workers: The bill makes eligible mental stress count as a personal injury for workplace insurance benefits and sets transition rules for claims, including some claims that can be filed by July 1, 2018. It also raises maximum workplace-safety fines on conviction: from $25,000 to $100,000 for an individual, and from $500,000 to $1.5 million for a corporation.
  • Pension members and beneficiaries: Administrators must report beneficiaries they cannot locate to a new registry. Some multi-employer plans may convert eligible benefits to target benefits, which can be reduced under the plan, but only after required notices, union consultation and the Superintendent’s consent.
  • Caregivers and some transit users: The bill creates an Ontario caregiver tax credit for eligible infirm dependants. It also broadens which transit passes qualify for the seniors’ transit tax credit, while counting only amounts paid by the person claiming it.
  • General public: Municipalities may use administrative penalties for certain Building Code Act violations. Ottawa must have a by-law for bilingual administration and services; its existing bilingualism by-law is recognized as meeting that requirement.

Money#

The bill appropriates $85 million for the river-remediation trust; it also authorizes large interim spending amounts while annual supply is pending, but those amounts are spending limits, not estimates of what will be spent.

  • The trust must be topped up from the Consolidated Revenue Fund to $425,000 when its balance falls below that amount after the annual notice date. Further appropriations may also be made.
  • The 2017–18 supplementary interim appropriation authorizes up to $4.29 billion for public-service expenses, $699 million for investments and $32.4 million for Legislative Office expenses. The 2018–19 interim appropriation authorizes up to $138.77 billion, $5.76 billion and $251.8 million for those categories, respectively.
  • No overall estimate of Bill 177’s costs, tax-credit cost, or costs to agencies and municipalities is in the available material. No publicly available information.

What is unclear#

  • Regulations must set key details for building evaluations, HOT-lane rules and tolls, and Indigenous-institute funding. The bill does not supply those details.
  • Many provisions have separate start dates or require proclamation. The available text does not establish when every provision began operating.
  • The bill does not give an overall cost estimate or say how much staffing and implementation will cost.
  • For the river trust, the panel advises on criteria, but the Minister sets the payment criteria after considering that advice. The materials do not explain how disagreements or the involvement of other Indigenous communities will work in practice.
  • The bill does not provide the full current versions of the Acts it amends, so changes to existing rules and overlaps with other programs could not all be verified.

Case for#

  • A dedicated trust and a panel that includes representatives appointed by the two most directly affected First Nations could give river cleanup a specific source of funding and a formal way to share decisions.
  • Building evaluations, public access to certain orders and records of complaints could help authorities identify safety problems and make enforcement more visible.
  • A registry could help people locate pension benefits they are owed. Clear notice and approval rules for target-benefit conversions could also give members and unions a defined role in the process.
  • HOT lanes give the Minister a way to set lane-use rules and tolls without making every highway lane a toll lane.

Case against#

  • Many important details are left to future regulations, so the bill itself does not show which buildings, energy providers, institutes or roads will be affected, or what the operating rules will be.
  • Building inspectors gain broader entry powers for compliance inspections. Even with limits on entering dwellings, that is a substantial increase in government inspection authority.
  • A target-benefit conversion can reduce benefits. The required notices, consultation and approval are safeguards, but the conversion may still shift financial risk to plan members.
  • The bill authorizes large spending limits and creates new duties for public bodies, but supplies no overall cost estimate. Without that information, taxpayers cannot judge the full financial effect.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017121401

    Passed85 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 177

    FOR · 48AGAINST · 37

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    48For

    • Liberal48

    37Against

    • PC22
    • NDP15
  2. Division No. 2017113001

    Passed85 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 177

    FOR · 46AGAINST · 39

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    46For

    • Liberal46

    39Against

    • PC22
    • NDP16
    • Independent1
  3. Division No. 2017112901

    Passed89 members voted

    Government Notice of Motion Number 43 for allocation of time on Bill 177, An Act to implement Budget measures and to enact and amend various statutes.

    FOR · 48AGAINST · 41

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    48For

    • Liberal48

    41Against

    • PC24
    • NDP17