Summary#
Bill 132, the Better for People, Smarter for Business Act, 2019, is an omnibus law that amends or repeals many Ontario laws and creates a new law on immunity from seizure for certain foreign cultural objects. Its stated goal is to reduce burdens on people and businesses; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. It was enacted as Chapter 14 of Ontario’s 2019 statutes, but some changes require a later proclamation to take effect.
- Environmental laws gain administrative penalties (money penalties issued outside a criminal court) for prescribed violations. Penalties may be increased by the violator’s financial benefit, and unpaid penalties can lead to licence or permit consequences.
- The rules for cosmetic pesticide use are rewritten: use generally requires the active ingredient to be approved by the Director and listed in a government document, subject to exceptions. Sale of pesticides for use on land is also restricted unless prescribed.
- The law gives the Minister new powers over forest-resource removal, wildlife disease zones, and some aggregate permits and licences. Some changes limit what decision-makers may consider or how existing rules apply.
- The Local Planning Appeal Support Centre is dissolved. Separate changes allow permanent residents to serve on public library boards, reduce the required number of library-board meetings, and expand degree-granting powers at two universities, when those provisions take effect.
- For unpaid Highway 407 and 407 East tolls, an enforcement fee may be charged after the person has received notice and 90 days have passed, without another invoice or notice of failure to pay.
- Certain designated institutions and transport carriers get protection from Ontario proceedings or remedies that would take custody or control of qualifying foreign cultural objects while they are here temporarily for display, if prescribed requirements are met.
What it means for you#
- People and businesses subject to environmental rules: A Director or, in prescribed circumstances, an officer may issue an administrative penalty for prescribed violations. For some violations, paying the penalty prevents conviction for the same violation; for others, prosecution may still follow. The rules include review and hearing routes, but details depend on regulations.
- Pesticide users and sellers: Cosmetic use of an active ingredient is prohibited unless the Director has found it appropriate and it is listed. Exceptions include agriculture, forestry, public health or safety, and golf-course uses subject to any prescribed conditions. Other exceptions may be set by regulation. The bill does not itself name the approved ingredients.
- Drivers with unpaid 407 or 407 East charges: After the notice and 90-day period, the road owner or Minister may charge an enforcement fee and notify the Registrar of Motor Vehicles. The notice must state the fee amount and warn that a vehicle permit may not be validated or issued.
- Forest operators: The Minister may issue permits to remove Crown forest resources for certain activities that require removal without renewal during the activity. A permit is allowed only if the activity is not a forest operation and required approvals or conditions under specified laws have been met. Permit terms may require security, reporting, or forest renewal. A permit does not give the permittee an interest in the land.
- People in a wildlife disease zone: A ministerial order may restrict or prohibit hunting, trapping, possession, sale, or other activities; require information or surrender of wildlife; and allow ministry staff or agents to enter private land for specified disease-control work, but not buildings or dwellings.
- Farm businesses, libraries, universities, and cultural institutions: The bill changes farm registration and payments to farm organizations; permits permanent residents to sit on library boards; expands degree-granting powers at Algoma University and OCAD University when those changes start; and protects qualifying cultural objects from certain claims while on temporary display.
Money#
The bill authorizes penalties, fees, and some required payments, but the available material gives no overall cost estimate.
- Penalty caps vary by law: up to $200,000 per violation under the Environmental Protection Act and Ontario Water Resources Act; up to $10,000 under the Nutrient Management Act; and up to $100,000 under the Pesticides Act and Safe Drinking Water Act. Some penalties may also include the financial benefit gained.
- Farm businesses required to obtain a registration number must pay an amount set by regulation to an accredited farm organization. The Director may charge accredited organizations an administration fee.
- Aggregate permit holders must pay annual fees set by regulation. Highway 407 enforcement fees recover costs of non-payment, but this material gives no fee amounts.
- AgriCorp may financially manage the Ontario Crop Insurance Fund. Money it collects under that Act and investment interest are not public money for purposes of the Financial Administration Act.
- The bill permits environmental penalty money to support environmental protection, conservation, and awareness activities. It does not estimate the revenue or spending involved.
What is unclear#
- Which provisions requiring proclamation have taken effect, and when the remaining changes start, are not stated in the supplied material.
- Regulations will determine many details, including which violations attract penalties, how penalty amounts are set, approved pesticide ingredients, farm registration thresholds and payments, and permit fees.
- The bill does not provide an overall estimate for government staffing, administration, enforcement, or costs to affected businesses and institutions.
- The process for consultation with Aboriginal communities on mining closure plans is left to regulations. The bill does not explain how communities will participate in other affected decisions.
- The parent Acts were not supplied, so current law could not be independently checked against the amendments beyond what the bill’s explanatory note describes.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to reduce administrative steps and update rules across many areas. A single law could remove outdated provisions and simplify some procedures.
- Administrative penalties can provide a way to respond to prescribed violations without relying only on criminal prosecution, while penalties tied to financial benefit aim to prevent people or businesses from profiting from non-compliance.
- Allowing some electronic notices and expanded university degree powers may give institutions more flexibility in how they operate.
- Disease-control zones could allow the Minister to set targeted restrictions and gather information when a wildlife disease may pose serious risks.
Case against#
- The bill gives ministers and officials significant discretion, including to set penalty rules by regulation and make orders affecting licences, permits, land use, or activities. Important practical limits are left to later rules.
- Administrative penalties can apply even if a person took reasonable steps to prevent a violation or honestly misunderstood the facts. The short seven-day deadline to request some reviews may also matter to people trying to challenge a penalty.
- The wildlife-zone power can restrict activities and permit entry onto private land without a case-by-case hearing process set out in the bill.
- The bill changes many distinct laws at once. That can make it harder for affected people to track what applies to them and when.