Summary#
Bill 19 would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act and Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act. Its apparent goal is to let the government designate places where drivers can safely stop to use certain wireless devices. The supplied title calls it the Safe Texting Zones Act, 2017, but the bill text’s short title says 2016.
- The Minister of Transportation may designate parts of a King’s Highway where the shoulder may be used as a texting zone. A highway designation does not take effect until required signs are erected on and approaching that area.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make regulations designating certain commuter parking lots, transit stations, and rest, service or other areas as texting zones. Regulations may require signs there.
- The Minister may make rules for highway texting zones, including conditions for their use, signs and markings, and exemptions from some highway-law requirements.
- Drivers could use a zone only in accordance with the bill and any regulations. Otherwise, driving, parking, standing or stopping a vehicle in the zone would not be allowed.
- The bill does not require any zones to be designated. It does not create a new agency or set out an application or review process.
What it means for you#
- Drivers: If a zone is designated, it would provide a place to stop safely to use a hand-held wireless communication device or another device prescribed under the Highway Traffic Act. Any rules or conditions for using the zone would still apply. The bill does not authorize texting while driving.
- Drivers: Highway traffic laws would continue to apply in a texting zone unless a regulation provides otherwise. The bill also says a highway texting zone is not part of the roadway for certain purposes under the Act.
- Government: The Minister could designate highway areas and make rules for them. The provincial cabinet could designate the specified parking lots, stations and other areas through regulations.
- Everyone else: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or the general rules about using devices while driving. The supplied material does not include the parent Acts, so current-law details and how these changes would fit with existing rules could not be verified.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill allows for signs and markings, but does not say who would pay for them or estimate their cost.
- It does not set out an appropriation, staffing requirement, fee, fine, or other funding source.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define what makes a stopping place “safe,” or set criteria for choosing locations.
- It does not say how many zones, if any, would be designated, or when designations would happen.
- The Minister’s regulations could set use conditions and exemptions, but those rules are not included in the bill.
- It is unclear who would pay for signs and markings, and how the rules would be enforced.
- The parent Acts were not supplied, so the bill’s changes could not be checked against current law or existing regulations.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it gives the government a way to identify places where drivers can stop safely before using a device, rather than using it while driving.
- Giving the Minister power to set conditions and provide signs could allow highway zones to be adapted to particular locations.
- Allowing regulations for commuter parking lots, transit stations and other specified areas could extend the option beyond highway shoulders.
Case against#
- The bill does not require the government to create any zones, so its practical effect would depend on later designations and regulations.
- The bill does not set location or safety criteria. Without those details, it is unclear how drivers would know which places are suitable.
- The bill allows exemptions from some highway-law requirements but does not specify which requirements could be exempted; that would depend on later regulations.
- Signage and administration could cost money, but the bill provides no estimate or funding plan.