Bill creates affordable energy plan

Summary#

Bill 172, the Affordable Energy Act, 2024, would create a new law; it does not amend an existing Act. It would require the Premier to prepare and implement a plan and establish Affordable Energy Ontario, a corporation without share capital. The bill’s stated goal is to make energy more affordable and resilient through distributed energy resources and deep building retrofits.

  • The Premier must consult the public, publish the plan within 12 months after the relevant section comes into force, and implement it on the plan’s timeline. The Premier must review it every two years and consult the public during each review.
  • The plan must set out government measures toward goals that include access to distributed energy resources, deep retrofits for all buildings, and certain rights for residential tenants. These are goals for the plan—not rights or retrofit duties that the bill itself immediately creates.
  • Affordable Energy Ontario’s objects include developing, overseeing, financing, facilitating and delivering programs for distributed energy resources and deep retrofits. Its programs should prioritize low- and middle-income residents and social and low-income rental housing.
  • The Agency must ensure unionized workers are hired for necessary work on projects it finances or facilitates, in accordance with regulations.
  • The Agency can employ or engage people and has natural-person powers to carry out its objects. Its governance and some limits on its powers depend on regulations. Required Agency funding must come from money appropriated by the Legislature.

What it means for you#

  • Residents, homeowners and building owners: The bill does not itself require you to retrofit a building or give you an immediate right to use or receive distributed energy resources. Those are goals the plan must address.
  • Residential tenants: The plan must include goals for a right to make prescribed minor home changes to reduce energy costs and a right to remain after a landlord’s retrofit. The bill does not itself create those rights or set the details.
  • Low- and middle-income residents and community energy organizations: Agency programs should give low- and middle-income residents priority, and capacity-building support should be provided to community energy organizations, municipalities and local distribution utilities. The bill does not guarantee a particular program or amount of assistance.
  • Workers: Unionized workers must be hired for necessary work on projects the Agency finances or facilitates, subject to regulations.
  • Taxpayers: The Agency’s required funding must come from legislative appropriations. The bill does not set an amount.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Legislature must appropriate money for the Agency’s purposes, but the bill gives no estimate of the amount.
  • The Agency may employ or otherwise engage people. The bill does not say how many or estimate staffing costs.
  • The Agency must use its revenues only for its objects and duties.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out the actual programs, eligibility rules, funding amounts, application processes, timelines for decisions or appeals.
  • The plan must describe proposed legal and regulatory changes, but the bill does not specify which changes will be made to create the proposed energy and tenant rights.
  • Regulations will set important details about the Agency, including its board, governance, staffing and some limits on its powers. Those regulations are not included here.
  • “Deep retrofitting” is not defined in the bill.
  • The supplied material does not explain how these programs would interact with existing energy programs or what current-law protections already apply.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a required plan could link energy affordability goals to specific government measures and a timeline, with public consultation and regular review.
  • The Agency could bring program development, financing and delivery for distributed energy resources and building retrofits under one corporation.
  • Prioritizing lower-income residents and social and low-income rental housing could direct attention to people the bill identifies as especially affected by energy costs.
  • Requiring unionized workers on Agency-financed or -facilitated project work could support the bill’s stated goal of unionized employment.

Case against#

  • The bill sets broad goals but does not itself establish the proposed energy or tenant rights, or require particular retrofit work. The practical benefits depend on later plans, programs and legal changes.
  • The Agency must receive appropriated money, but the bill provides no cost estimate or program funding limits.
  • Important safeguards and operating details are left to regulations, including the Agency’s governance and stakeholder participation.
  • The bill does not explain how the Agency’s programs would fit with existing programs or how people would qualify for assistance.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2024041502

    Defeated103 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 172

    AGAINST · 69FOR · 34

    69Against

    • PC68
    • Independent1

    34For

    • NDP23
    • Liberal7
    • Green2
    • Independent2