Summary#
Bill 201, the Respecting Municipal Authority Over Landfilling Sites Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Environmental Assessment Act and Environmental Protection Act. Its stated goal is to require support from municipal councils or band councils before a landfilling site is established. The bill creates a condition on two existing provincial approvals; it does not create a new agency or service.
- The Minister could not approve an undertaking involving a landfilling site within a municipality or on a reserve unless the relevant municipal council or band council passed a resolution supporting the site.
- The Director could not issue an environmental compliance approval for establishing such a site without that council resolution.
- The bill also makes related changes to provisions that refer to those approval powers.
What it means for you#
- Municipal and band councils: Their support, expressed through a resolution, would be required before the specified provincial approvals could be granted for a site in their area.
- Landfill proponents and operators: They could not obtain either of those approvals for establishing a site without the required resolution. The bill does not itself ban landfills or remove other approval requirements.
- Residents and the general public: The bill does not create a public application, hearing, appeal, or consultation process.
- Provincial officials: The Minister and Director would be barred from granting the specified approvals without the resolution.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided. No publicly available information.
- The bill does not state a new fee, fine, appropriation, or staffing requirement.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current parent Acts, so I could not verify how these new conditions interact with existing approval rules.
- The bill’s added provisions do not define “landfilling site”; the supplied material does not show whether the parent Acts define it.
- The bill does not set out how councils would consider a proposed site, how long a decision could take, or whether a council must give reasons.
- It does not say how the rule applies if a site’s location involves more than one municipality or a reserve.
- The bill sets no start-up process beyond saying it would come into force on Royal Assent.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that local elected councils would have a formal say before the province grants the specified approvals for a landfill in their area.
- Requiring support at both approval points could prevent those approvals from proceeding without a council resolution.
- The bill provides this local role through existing approval systems rather than creating a new agency.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill does not explain how councils should weigh a proposal or what process should apply, leaving important decisions to local councils without rules in this bill.
- A council’s lack of support would block the specified approvals, but the bill does not describe a way to resolve a disagreement or appeal that decision.
- It is unclear how the new condition would interact with other requirements under the two Acts or with decisions involving overlapping areas.