Summary#
Bill 204, the Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry Special Purpose Account Transparency Act, 2018, would amend the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act, 1997. Its stated goal is to narrow the purposes for which money in an existing account can be paid out and add advice and a way to receive public complaints.
- The Minister would no longer be allowed to pay account money for the purpose removed from the Act: a matter related to people’s activities as they interact with or affect fish or wildlife populations.
- The Minister would have to establish an advisory committee on how the account operates. Its members must be licence or authorization holders, ecology experts, or representatives of businesses related to fish or wildlife.
- The Minister would also have to establish a procedure for receiving public complaints about decisions on payments from the account.
- The bill does not create a new account or organization. It changes rules for an existing account in Ontario’s Consolidated Revenue Fund (the government’s main account).
What it means for you#
- People concerned about account payments: The Minister would have to set up a procedure to receive complaints about payment decisions. The bill does not require the Minister to investigate complaints, change a decision, or give complainants an appeal.
- Licence or authorization holders, ecology experts, and related businesses: People from these groups must make up the advisory committee. The bill does not say how members are chosen or how many there must be.
- The Minister: Must establish the committee and complaints procedure. The bill does not set out how either one must operate.
- General public: The bill does not directly change fishing or hunting licences, offences, or penalties.
- The bill is a proposal; the supplied material does not give its current status or show that it is in force. It would start on Royal Assent.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill does not set a new appropriation, fee, or payment amount.
- The Minister would have to establish a committee and complaints procedure, but the bill gives no cost, staffing, or funding estimate.
What is unclear#
- The current version of the parent Act was not supplied, so the full list of payment purposes that would remain—and the exact current rules—could not be checked.
- The bill does not explain how the committee is appointed, how it gives advice, or whether its advice must be made public or acted on.
- It does not set out how complaints are handled, whether decisions must be reconsidered, or whether complainants can appeal.
- It does not explain how the account’s remaining permitted payment purposes would be interpreted or how the change would affect existing payments.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to limit the uses of money received by the Crown under the fish and wildlife law.
- A committee including licence holders, ecology experts, or related business representatives could bring relevant experience to advice on how the account operates.
- A required complaints procedure could give members of the public a defined way to raise concerns about payment decisions.
Case against#
- The bill removes one category of permitted payments but does not explain the practical effect on programs or activities that may have relied on it.
- The advisory committee only advises; the bill does not require the Minister to follow or publish its advice.
- The complaints procedure is required, but the bill sets no rules for responses, reviews, or remedies. Its practical value is therefore unclear.
- The committee and procedure may require public resources, but no cost estimate or funding plan is provided.