Curb account payments for fish and wildlife

Summary#

Bill 51, the Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry Special Purpose Account Transparency Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act, 1997. Its stated goal is greater transparency in decisions about a separate account holding money the Crown receives under that Act.

  • The bill would remove a category of permitted payments: payments for matters related to people’s activities as they interact with or affect fish or wildlife populations.
  • The Minister would have to establish an advisory committee on how the account operates. Its members must be licence or authorization holders, ecology experts, or representatives of businesses related to fish or wildlife.
  • The Minister would also have to establish a procedure for the public to complain about the Minister’s payment decisions.
  • The committee would advise; the bill does not give it power to approve or direct payments. The complaint procedure is not described as an appeal or a way to overturn decisions.
  • The bill would take effect on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not state whether it has become law.

What it means for you#

  • Members of the public: You would be able to make complaints through a procedure the Minister must establish. The bill does not set out how complaints are handled or require the Minister to change a payment decision.
  • Licence and authorization holders, ecology experts, and related businesses: People in these groups could be committee members. The bill does not give anyone a guaranteed seat or explain how members are chosen.
  • People and organizations affected by account payments: The Minister would no longer be able to use the account for the removed category of payments. The bill does not otherwise change licence rules or create a new service.
  • Taxpayers: The bill changes rules for a government account, but does not set a tax, fee, fine, or public benefit.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The account contains money the Crown receives under the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act, 1997. The bill restricts one category of payments from it.
  • The Minister must establish a committee and a complaints procedure, which may require staff or other resources; the bill gives no estimate.
  • The supplied material does not say how much money is in the account or how the restriction would change future payments.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Act was not supplied, so the existing permitted payment rules and how this change fits with them could not be verified.
  • The bill does not explain how committee members would be selected, how many there would be, or whether each listed group must be represented.
  • It does not set rules, timelines, or reporting requirements for the committee’s advice.
  • It does not explain how complaints would be assessed, answered, or followed up.
  • The phrase describing the removed payment category is not further defined.

Case for#

  • The bill would narrow what account money can be used for, which could make the Minister’s payment decisions more focused.
  • A required advisory committee could bring licence holders, ecology experts, and related businesses into advice on how the account operates.
  • A required complaints procedure would give members of the public a formal way to raise concerns about payment decisions.

Case against#

  • The bill does not require the Minister to follow the committee’s advice or explain whether advice was accepted.
  • A complaints procedure is required, but the bill does not set out what response complainants can expect or whether a decision can be reconsidered.
  • The bill removes a payment category without explaining which payments would fall within it, leaving uncertainty about the practical effect.
  • The new committee and procedure may require resources, but their costs and staffing needs are not stated.