Label Altered Images to Fight Eating Disorders

Summary#

Bill 205, the Combatting Eating Disorders in Ontario Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law. Its stated goal is to address digitally altered images and promote awareness of eating disorders; it would take effect one year after receiving Royal Assent.

  • A person publishing digitally altered or retouched photos or videos for a commercial purpose would have to display a prescribed notice and keep an unaltered copy, unless regulations provide an exemption.
  • The labeling rule would not apply to people in the commercial film, television or video industry. The minister would have to review related regulations and publish recommendations, but would not have to make changes.
  • The Government and Consumer Services Minister would have to appoint inspectors only if they choose to, and would have to run an annual eating-disorder awareness campaign.
  • The Health and Long-Term Care Minister could give awards to people who, in the minister’s view, have taken meaningful action to reduce eating disorders.
  • A person who breaks the labeling or record-keeping rules could face a fine of up to $25,000 for a first offence, $50,000 for a second, and $75,000 for a third or later offence.

What it means for you#

  • People and businesses publishing commercial images: If the image changes a person’s body shape, skin tone or complexion, hair, face, or other physical features, the publisher would have to show a notice in the form and manner set by regulations and retain an unaltered copy. An inspector could request that copy.
  • Commercial film, television and video industry: People engaged in this industry would be exempt from the labeling rule. The minister’s review could recommend changes to industry regulations, but the bill would not itself require those changes.
  • People making complaints: Anyone could complain about an alleged breach. The complaint process would be set by regulations.
  • Ontario residents: The minister would have to run an annual campaign emphasizing healthy views of body image and beauty. The bill does not require a particular treatment, service, or benefit for people with eating disorders.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated cost.

  • The bill would require an annual awareness campaign and allow the appointment of inspectors, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The Health Minister could issue awards, but the bill gives no award amounts or funding source.
  • The bill sets maximum fines for offences but does not estimate fine revenue.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves “commercial purpose” and “meaningful action” undefined. Regulations would set the required notice and could exempt images not used to advertise a product or service.
  • The regulations would determine record-keeping rules, inspector powers and duties, and how complaints work. Those details are not in the supplied text.
  • The bill does not say how inspections would be selected, or set out a review or appeal process for decisions.
  • The scope of the film, television and video industry exception is not explained.
  • The bill does not say how the awareness campaign or awards would be funded.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make some digitally altered commercial images identifiable to viewers and to preserve the original image for inspection.
  • A public campaign could draw attention to healthy body image, alongside the rules for commercial images.
  • The minister’s review could identify whether existing rules for film, television and video should address altered images or unhealthy body-image standards.

Case against#

  • The labeling rule would not cover people engaged in the commercial film, television or video industry, and the bill does not require that industry’s rules to change after the review.
  • Key details—including the notice, inspection powers and complaint process—would depend on regulations not included in the bill.
  • The bill creates duties and possible fines without providing a cost estimate or specifying how much staff and enforcement would be needed.