Bill would curb sending graphic fetal images

Summary#

Bill 41, the Viewer Discretion Act (Images of Fetuses), 2021, would create a new Ontario law. Its stated goal is to regulate the mailing and other distribution of graphic images of aborted or otherwise non-viable fetuses.

  • Anyone distributing such an image would have to put it in an opaque envelope, describe its contents on the outside, and clearly identify the sender.
  • A person who breaks the rule would commit an offence and, if convicted, face a fine of $100 per image.
  • The bill says it would come into force on Royal Assent. It does not amend an existing Act.

What it means for you#

  • People or organizations sending or distributing images: They would have to meet all three envelope and sender-identification conditions. The rule applies to mailing and “otherwise” distributing images.
  • People receiving images: The bill would require a description of the contents on the envelope’s exterior, but does not create a process for recipients to request or refuse images.
  • General public: The bill would not ban distribution outright; it would make distribution an offence only if the stated conditions were not met.
  • Enforcement: A fine could be imposed after conviction. The bill does not name an enforcement agency.

Money#

The bill sets a fine but provides no estimate of public costs or revenue.

  • The fine is $100 for each image involved in a violation, on conviction.
  • No publicly available information on enforcement, court, or implementation costs is included in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “graphic image,” “otherwise distribute,” or “aborted or otherwise non-viable fetus.”
  • It does not explain how the envelope requirements apply to distribution that does not involve an envelope.
  • It does not name who would investigate or prosecute offences, or set out enforcement procedures, defences, or an appeal process.
  • The supplied material does not describe current law or whether similar rules already apply. No publicly available information is provided here on that point.
  • The supplied material does not state the bill’s status or whether it has passed.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let people see a description of the contents and identify the sender before opening an envelope.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that it sets clear conditions for distribution rather than banning the images altogether.
  • A fixed fine per image could make the stated penalty clear.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define key terms, so people may not know which images or forms of distribution are covered.
  • The envelope conditions may be difficult to apply to distribution that does not use an envelope; the bill does not explain how that would work.
  • The $100 fine applies per image, with no maximum stated in the bill. The total penalty could therefore depend on how many images are counted.
  • The bill creates an offence but does not specify who enforces it or how cases would be handled.