Summary#
Bill 29, the Combatting Eating Disorders in Ontario Act, 2018, would create a new law. Its stated goal is to address digitally altered images and promote awareness of eating disorders; these are aims, not guaranteed results.
- A person publishing an image or video for a commercial purpose would have to label it if digital editing changed a person’s body shape, skin tone, hair, face, or other physical features. Regulations would set the label and could exempt some images.
- Publishers covered by the rule would have to keep the unaltered version and provide it to an inspector on request, following rules set by regulation. The rule would not apply to people in the commercial film, television, or video industry.
- The Minister of Government and Consumer Services could appoint inspectors and would have to run an annual eating-disorder awareness campaign.
- The minister would have to review Ontario regulations related to the commercial film, television, and video industry within one year after the Act came into force, and publish any recommendations.
- The Minister of Health and Long-Term Care could give awards to people who, in the minister’s view, took meaningful action to reduce eating disorders.
- A person who breaks the image rules could face a fine of up to $25,000 for a first offence, $50,000 for a second, or $75,000 for a third or later offence.
What it means for you#
- Businesses and others publishing commercial images or videos: If the rule applies, you would have to display the prescribed label prominently and keep the unaltered version. You would have to provide that version to an inspector on request. The bill does not set the label wording or record-keeping details.
- People in the commercial film, television, or video industry: The image-label rule would not apply to you. The minister’s review could recommend changes to rules for this industry, but the bill does not itself require the industry to add disclaimers.
- Members of the public: Anyone could complain about an alleged breach, under a process to be set by regulation. The bill does not create a direct eating-disorder treatment or other health-care service.
- Government: The responsible minister would have to run an annual awareness campaign and review and publish recommendations. The health minister could, but would not have to, issue awards.
Money#
No cost estimate or funding amount is given. No publicly available information.
- The bill would require an annual campaign and a review, but gives no cost or staffing estimates.
- It would allow fines for violations, but does not estimate how many fines might be imposed or how much money they might raise.
- The bill does not set fees or award amounts.
What is unclear#
- “Commercial purpose” and “meaningful action” are not defined in the bill.
- Regulations would determine the label, how records must be kept, the inspection rules, the complaint process, and the award rules. Those details are not in the bill text provided.
- Regulations could exempt images or videos, and could exempt material not used to advertise a product or service. The scope of any exemptions is not set out.
- The bill does not explain how inspections or complaints would work in practice, or what further steps could follow a complaint.
- The bill would start one year after Royal Assent, but the material provided does not say whether it received Royal Assent.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make commercial retouching of physical features visible to the public.
- A possible argument for the label is that people seeing an altered image would have notice that it does not show an unaltered appearance.
- An annual awareness campaign could draw attention to body image and eating disorders, as the bill’s stated goal proposes.
- The review could identify whether existing rules for film, television, and video should address altered images or unhealthy body-image standards.
Case against#
- The label and record-keeping rules depend on later regulations. Without them, publishers and the public cannot know exactly what the requirements would be.
- The commercial film, television, and video industry is excluded from the image-label rule, even though the bill asks the minister to review rules for that industry.
- The bill allows substantial fines but does not set out inspection procedures or the complaint process; those details are left to regulations.
- The bill requires an awareness campaign but does not specify its content, budget, or how its effects would be assessed.