New rule on graphic fetal images

Summary#

Bill 80, Viewer Discretion Act (Images of Fetuses), 2023, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. It would restrict how graphic images of aborted or otherwise non-viable fetuses are sent or distributed. The bill gives no express goal; its design appears intended to let people identify the contents before opening an envelope.

  • Anyone mailing or otherwise distributing such an image would have to put it in an opaque envelope, describe the contents on the outside, and clearly identify the sender.
  • A person convicted of breaking the rule would be liable to a fine of $100 for each image mailed or distributed.
  • The Act would start on the day it receives Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Anyone sending or distributing the images: If the bill became law, you would have to meet all three envelope conditions. A person convicted of failing to do so could be fined $100 per image.
  • People receiving them: The envelope would have to be opaque and describe its contents and identify the sender. The bill does not ban distribution outright or require the recipient’s consent.

Money#

No publicly available information on public spending or enforcement costs.

  • The bill would create a fine of $100 per image for a person convicted of an offence. It does not say how fine revenue would be used.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “graphic image,” “fetus,” or “otherwise distribute.”
  • It does not explain how the rule applies to different ways of distributing an image, beyond mailing and “otherwise” distributing it.
  • It does not name who would investigate or prosecute offences, or set out an enforcement process.
  • The text does not set out exceptions or defences.
  • The supplied material does not say whether the bill has received Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that an opaque envelope and a description of its contents could help recipients avoid seeing an image unexpectedly.
  • The bill would allow distribution if the sender follows the stated conditions, rather than banning the images outright.

Case against#

  • One concern is that key terms, including “graphic image” and “otherwise distribute,” are undefined, leaving the rule’s reach unclear.
  • The bill does not explain how the offence would be investigated or handled, or identify any exceptions.
  • The fine is charged per image, with no maximum amount stated in the bill. A distribution involving multiple images could therefore lead to multiple $100 fines if there is a conviction.