Summary#
Bill 6, the Ministry of Community and Social Services Amendment Act (Social Assistance Research Commission), 2016, would amend Ontario’s Ministry of Community and Social Services Act. It would require the government to establish a nine-member advisory commission to recommend social assistance rates and other policy; its stated goal is to provide research and advice about social assistance. The bill does not itself set benefit rates or require the government to adopt the commission’s recommendations.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council would appoint nine members with specified expertise. The membership must include people with disability-related expertise, expertise on the challenges faced by Indigenous people in Ontario, and people who receive or recently received Ontario Works or disability support.
- The commission would have to define regions using economic geography and local living costs, then recommend social assistance rates for each region every year.
- In making rate recommendations, it would have to analyze listed basic needs and other eligible benefits, plus additional costs faced by people with disabilities and Ontario Works recipients with long-term barriers to employment.
- The commission could recommend extra periodic benefits, including monthly benefits, for Ontario Works recipients with long-term barriers to employment.
- It would have to recommend policy on precarious work, child support payments, and the interaction of social assistance with workplace-injury benefits, at least every five years.
- The Minister would have to publish the commission’s reports within 30 days and respond in writing to annual-report recommendations within 60 days. The bill would take effect six months after Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- People receiving Ontario Works or disability support: The commission would recommend rates and policies, but the bill would not directly change your payment, eligibility, or benefits.
- People receiving Ontario Works who face long-term barriers to employment: The commission could recommend additional periodic benefits for this group; the bill would not itself create those benefits.
- People with disabilities, Indigenous people, and other groups named in the bill: Their circumstances would be part of the commission’s required expertise or research. The bill does not set out a process for these groups to take part in the commission’s work.
- Taxpayers and the public: The commission would be an advisory group under the Ministry Act, not a new independent agency. The public would be able to see its reports and the Minister’s written response.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill allows regulations to cover members’ remuneration and the retention of experts, but gives no amounts or cost estimate.
- It requires the commission to make recommendations; it does not appropriate money or itself raise or lower benefit payments.
What is unclear#
- The parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify how this bill would fit with its current provisions or existing government processes.
- The bill does not say how the commission would gather evidence, consult affected people, or decide between competing recommendations.
- It does not define key terms such as “basic necessities,” “long term barriers to employment,” or “precarious employment.”
- Regulations could set details such as members’ terms and remuneration, but those regulations are not included.
- The bill does not require the Minister or government to accept or implement recommendations.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that regional recommendations could account for differences in housing and other living costs across Ontario.
- Requiring analysis of food, shelter, transportation, disability-related costs, and other listed needs could make rate recommendations more detailed.
- Required representation and expertise could bring relevant knowledge, including experience receiving assistance, into the commission’s work.
- Public reports and a required ministerial response would make recommendations and the government’s response visible.
Case against#
- The commission could recommend changes, but the bill would not require the government to make them. Its practical effect would depend on decisions outside the commission.
- The bill does not specify the commission’s budget, research capacity, or consultation process, which could affect the quality and reach of its work.
- The required membership and broad research topics do not guarantee that every affected group would be consulted or that their views would shape recommendations.
- A possible trade-off is that creating the commission and preparing reports could require public resources, while the available material gives no cost estimate.