Advisory Commission on Social Assistance Rates

Summary#

Bill 60 would amend Ontario’s Ministry of Community and Social Services Act to require an advisory group called the Social Assistance Research Commission. The bill’s official short title is the Ministry of Community and Social Services Amendment Act (Social Assistance Research Commission), 2018; the supplied title line says 2019. Its stated goal is to improve research and recommendations on social assistance rates and policy, not to set new benefit rates itself.

  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council would appoint nine members with specified expertise, including people with current or recent experience receiving Ontario Works or disability support.
  • The Commission would define regions based on economic geography and local living costs, then recommend social assistance rates for each region every year.
  • Its rate recommendations must assess listed basic needs, extra costs related to disability and long-term barriers to employment, and other statutory benefits recipients may qualify for.
  • At least every five years, or when directed by the Minister, it would recommend policy on precarious work, child support and workplace injury benefits. It may recommend extra periodic benefits for some Ontario Works recipients facing long-term barriers to employment.
  • The Minister must publish the Commission’s reports within 30 days of receiving them and publish a written response to the annual report’s recommendations within 60 days. The bill would take effect six months after Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • People receiving Ontario Works or disability support: The bill would create a process for recommendations about rates and related policy. It would not itself raise, lower or otherwise change benefit amounts or eligibility.
  • People with disabilities and people facing long-term barriers to employment: Their additional costs must be considered in the Commission’s work. The Commission may recommend extra periodic benefits for the specified Ontario Works recipients, but the bill does not require those benefits to be created.
  • People receiving child support or workplace injury benefits while on social assistance: The Commission must recommend policy on how those benefits interact with social assistance. The bill does not change those rules directly.
  • Government: The Lieutenant Governor in Council must establish and appoint the Commission. The Minister appoints its chair and must publish its reports and a written response to its annual recommendations.

Money#

The bill requires a Commission, but no cost estimate is provided.

  • Regulations may set members’ remuneration and rules for retaining experts; the bill gives no amounts.
  • The bill does not appropriate a specific sum or directly change benefit payments.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how the Commission would calculate rates, choose regional boundaries or gather and assess evidence.
  • It does not require the government to adopt the Commission’s recommendations. The required written response is not required to accept them.
  • The bill does not explain how recommendations would affect existing programs or how people could provide input.
  • “Long-term barriers to employment” and “adequate standards of living” are not defined in the supplied text.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that rates based on regional costs and an explicit list of basic needs could make recommendations more grounded in living costs.
  • Requiring attention to disability-related costs and barriers to employment could help identify expenses that a general rate assessment might miss.
  • Including members who receive or recently received assistance could bring direct experience into the Commission’s work.
  • Public reports and a required Minister’s response would make the recommendations and government response visible.

Case against#

  • The Commission would recommend rates and policies, but the bill does not require the government to put them into effect.
  • The bill leaves important methods and terms open, including how costs are measured and what counts as a long-term barrier to employment.
  • Establishing and staffing the Commission, paying members or retaining experts may cost money, but the bill gives no estimate.
  • The Commission’s recommendations could have limited practical effect if the government does not adopt them.