Summary#
Bill 7, the Promoting Affordable Housing Act, 2016, amends several Ontario laws and repeals the Elderly Persons’ Housing Aid Act. Its stated goal is to promote affordable housing; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. The Act received Royal Assent, but some changes depended on later regulations or proclamation before taking effect.
- It lets municipalities require affordable housing units in some new or redeveloped projects. Municipalities prescribed by regulation must adopt policies and, if those policies are in their official plan, pass by-laws to put them into effect.
- It gives local municipalities duties to receive certain rental-maintenance complaints, inspect when they consider it necessary, monitor compliance and investigate specified offences.
- It requires local housing service managers to count people who are homeless as directed by the Minister and to report information to the Minister and the public.
- It changes consent rules for certain social-housing property transactions and allows some other forms of housing assistance to count toward rent-geared-to-income service requirements, if approved or specified under the rules.
- It limits development charges for a second dwelling unit in prescribed classes of proposed new homes, and caps certain planning application fees for developments that include affordable housing.
What it means for you#
- People seeking affordable housing: In municipalities covered by the rules, some developments may have to include affordable units and keep them affordable for a set period. The law does not set the key affordability details itself; regulations or municipal by-laws must do so. Municipalities cannot accept money instead of providing required units, though regulations may allow some units to be built elsewhere.
- Tenants receiving rent-geared-to-income assistance: In specified rental units, a landlord cannot end a tenancy solely because a tenant loses eligibility for this assistance or fails to take a step needed to keep it. A matching protection applies to members of specified non-profit housing co-operatives.
- Tenants with maintenance complaints: Where the prescribed standards apply in a local municipality, the municipality must receive written complaints from current tenants and cause an inspection it considers necessary. Municipalities must also monitor compliance and investigate certain alleged offences. The Act does not require an inspection for every complaint.
- Municipalities and housing service managers: Municipalities may have new planning, monitoring, complaint-handling and enforcement duties. Service managers must conduct homelessness enumerations when and as directed, and provide information to the Minister and the public.
- People creating a second unit in a new home: Municipalities cannot charge a development charge for a second unit in prescribed classes of proposed new residential buildings, subject to prescribed restrictions. This is not a general exemption for every new home.
- People and organizations dealing with social-housing property: Certain housing providers need written consent from the service manager before transferring, mortgaging or developing covered projects or land. For some transfers, including specified cases involving a receiver or Minister-appointed directors, the Minister’s consent is required.
Money#
No publicly available information on the Act’s total public cost or expected savings.
- Municipalities and service managers must take on new duties, but the material gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- Development-charge exemptions and caps on certain planning fees may reduce revenue for municipalities; the material does not estimate the amounts.
- The Act does not set a general affordable-housing grant or payment to tenants.
What is unclear#
- Which municipalities and types of development are covered depends on regulations. The material does not identify them.
- The Act leaves important affordable-housing details to regulations or municipal by-laws, including eligibility, prices or rents, the number of units, and how long they must remain affordable.
- The rules for assessing and counting homelessness, including the categories the Minister may clarify, are not set out in the Act.
- The Act does not specify how much the new municipal and service-manager duties will cost, or how that work will be funded.
- Some provisions had to start by proclamation or depend on regulations. The supplied material does not establish when every provision took effect.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that requiring affordable units in some market developments could add homes that remain affordable over time.
- Public assessment reports, monitoring procedures and agreements registered against land could help show whether those requirements are being met.
- Local handling of rental-maintenance complaints could give municipalities a direct role in addressing local housing conditions.
- Counting homelessness and reporting the results could give the province and the public more consistent information about the issue.
Case against#
- The main affordability rules depend on later regulations and local choices. Until those details are set, the reach and effect of inclusionary zoning are uncertain.
- Municipalities and service managers receive new duties, but the material does not say how much staff time or money they will need.
- Limits on appeals for inclusionary-zoning policies and related decisions may reduce some opportunities to challenge them; the Minister remains an exception.
- The law allows alternative forms of housing assistance to count toward rent-geared-to-income service requirements if approved or specified, but does not explain the standards for those alternatives.