Summary#
Bill 134, Affordable Homes and Good Jobs Act, 2023, is enacted as Chapter 18 of Ontario’s 2023 statutes. It amends the Development Charges Act, 1997 and the former St. Thomas - Central Elgin Boundary Adjustment Act, 2023, which it renames the Supporting Manufacturing in St. Thomas Act, 2023. The bill’s title signals goals of affordable homes and good jobs; it does not guarantee either result.
- For development-charge exemptions, the bill changes how an “affordable residential unit” is measured. Rent and purchase prices must be below both an income-based limit and a market-based limit.
- The Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing must set the income-based limits using local household incomes: the income of a household at the 60th percentile, with rent or annual housing costs set at 30% of that income.
- The City of St. Thomas may give assistance to 1000511515 Ontario Inc. during 2023–2036, or another year set by regulation. Assistance can include grants, discounted or free land, and exemptions from levies, charges or fees.
- For grants other than land grants or discounted land deals, and for exemptions, the total assistance cannot exceed the company’s municipal property taxes and fees or charges that would otherwise be owed during the assistance period. The cap does not include land grants or discounted land deals.
- The bill allows the Minister to make regulations that restrict, limit or set conditions on the City’s assistance powers, including limiting where assistance applies.
What it means for you#
- Renters and homebuyers: The new income-and-market tests affect which units can qualify as affordable for development-charge exemptions. The bill does not set rents or sale prices for all homes, create a housing benefit, or guarantee that a unit will be available to you at a particular price.
- Municipalities: The Minister must identify the income-based rent and purchase-price limits for the relevant units in a government bulletin. The bill’s changes concern the affordable-unit test; it does not change the text about attainable units.
- The City of St. Thomas and the named company: The City may provide the listed forms of assistance, directly or indirectly, but is not required to do so. The bill does not set an application or approval process.
- Local taxpayers: The City could provide grants, waive fees or charges, or transfer land below market value or for free. The bill does not require any particular assistance to be granted.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The St. Thomas provisions authorize possible municipal assistance, but do not give a spending estimate. The stated cap covers grants other than land grants or discounted land deals, and exemptions; land assistance is excluded from that cap.
- The bill gives no estimate of how development-charge exemptions under the revised affordability test could affect municipal revenue.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the parent Acts, so the current rules and other conditions around development-charge exemptions could not be checked against the full Development Charges Act, 1997.
- The bill refers to a government bulletin that can be amended over time, but the supplied material does not give its current figures or explain how the Minister will calculate them in practice.
- The bill does not set out how the City would decide whether, when or how much assistance to provide, or how the public would be told about decisions.
- Regulations could add other forms of assistance, change the assistance period, or set limits and conditions. No regulations are included in the supplied material.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the revised affordability test is that it ties limits to local incomes as well as local market prices, rather than relying on only one measure.
- Using a 60th-percentile household income and a 30% housing-cost measure gives the Minister a stated method for setting the income-based limits.
- Allowing St. Thomas to offer financial or land assistance could give the City tools to support the named company’s activity in the city.
Case against#
- The bill does not explain how the St. Thomas assistance would be chosen, reported or assessed. That leaves important decisions to the City and to regulations.
- The assistance power applies to one named company and may apply anywhere in the city, while land grants and discounted land deals are outside the bill’s stated assistance cap.
- The affordability test depends in part on the Minister’s judgment and a bulletin that can change. The bill does not specify how often the figures must be updated.