Asbestos use ban in public buildings

Summary#

Bill 88 would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. The bill text gives its short title as the Asbestos Use Prohibition Act, 2016 (the supplied heading labels it 2017). Its stated goal is to prohibit asbestos use and make information about asbestos in provincially owned or leased buildings public.

  • It would ban anyone from using, reusing, importing, transporting or selling six named asbestos fibres: actinolite, amosite, anthophyllite, chrysotile, crocidolite and tremolite. It would also ban causing or permitting those activities. There is an exception for existing products containing asbestos if the person does not know they contain it.
  • The Minister of Labour would have to create and maintain an online register of provincially owned or leased buildings containing asbestos. This includes buildings owned or leased by Crown bodies and entities in the broader public sector.
  • Owners or lessees of those buildings would have to report whether asbestos is present and, if so, where it is. If someone does or plans work to reduce asbestos in a building, that person must notify the owner; the owner must then report the work to the Minister.
  • The Minister could appoint inspectors. After receiving a complaint, an inspector could enter and inspect a provincially owned or leased building, without using force, and could examine records, take samples, question people and, in specified circumstances, direct an employer or person in charge to comply.
  • Regulations would set reporting time limits and fine amounts. The bill itself does not set those amounts.

What it means for you#

  • Businesses and the public: You could not knowingly use, reuse, import, transport or sell asbestos in Ontario, or cause or permit those activities. The exception is limited to existing products containing asbestos when the person does not know they contain it.
  • Owners and lessees of covered buildings: You would have to report asbestos information and report work to reduce asbestos. The information would be published online. The bill does not require owners to remove asbestos.
  • People doing work to reduce asbestos: You would have to notify the building owner if you do or plan to do that work.
  • Employers and people at inspected buildings: You would have to comply with relevant inspector demands for records or things, and must not obstruct an inspection, refuse relevant questions or knowingly give false or misleading information.
  • The Ministry of Labour: It would have to maintain and publish the register. It could appoint inspectors, but the bill does not require inspections in every case.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require the Ministry to create, maintain and publish the register, and would allow it to appoint inspectors. It gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Building owners and lessees would have reporting duties. The bill gives no estimate of their costs.
  • Fine amounts would be set later by regulation; no amounts are provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set the reporting deadlines or fine amounts, and regulations could exempt people or classes of people from the reporting duties.
  • It does not explain how the register would be administered beyond requiring it to list covered buildings containing asbestos and be published online.
  • “Use,” “work to reduce asbestos” and other key terms are not defined in the bill.
  • The inspection power to enter a covered building applies after a complaint is received. The bill does not set complaint procedures or inspection timelines.
  • The supplied material does not establish how these rules compare with current Ontario law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent asbestos from being used or traded in Ontario, with a limited exception for people unaware that an existing product contains it.
  • A public register could make information about asbestos in provincial and broader public-sector buildings easier to find.
  • Requiring owners to report asbestos and updates after work could help keep that information current.
  • Inspectors would have tools to check compliance, while entry would be limited to covered buildings after a complaint and inspectors could not use force.

Case against#

  • The ban covers transport and sale as well as use, and the bill does not explain how it would apply to different situations involving existing products.
  • The bill does not require asbestos to be removed from buildings; it creates reporting duties and a register instead.
  • Fine amounts, reporting deadlines and possible exemptions are left to later regulations, so the bill alone does not show the full obligations or penalties.
  • The Ministry would have to run the register and could appoint inspectors, but the bill provides no funding or staffing estimate.