Summary#
Bill 66, the Asbestos Use Prohibition Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. It would prohibit several activities involving asbestos and require a public register of asbestos in provincially owned or leased buildings. Its stated goal is to prohibit asbestos use.
- No person could use, reuse, import, transport or sell asbestos in Ontario, or cause or permit those activities. The exception is for existing products containing asbestos when the person does not know they contain asbestos.
- The Minister of Labour would have to establish and maintain a public register of provincially owned or leased buildings containing asbestos.
- Owners and lessees of those buildings would have to report whether asbestos is present and, if so, where it is. A person doing or planning work to reduce asbestos would have to notify the owner; the owner would then have to report the work to the Minister.
- The Minister could appoint inspectors. After receiving a complaint, an inspector could enter and inspect a provincially owned or leased building, examine or demand relevant records, take samples, question people and direct an employer to comply with the ban.
- Contraventions and certain failures to report, obstruct an inspector or provide information would be offences, with fines set by regulations.
What it means for you#
- People and businesses handling asbestos: The ban would apply to the listed activities, including causing or permitting them. The exception is limited to existing products whose asbestos content the person does not know about.
- Owners and lessees of provincial public buildings: They would have to report to the Minister within a time set by regulations. The term covers Crown buildings, buildings of Crown agents and government agencies, boards or commissions, and buildings of entities in the broader public sector.
- People doing or planning work to reduce asbestos in those buildings: They would have to notify the building owner. The owner, not the person doing the work, would have to submit the report to the Minister.
- Employers and people holding relevant records: They could have to comply with an inspector’s direction or produce records. They could not obstruct an inspection, refuse to answer relevant questions, or knowingly give false or misleading information.
- General public: The register would be published on a Government of Ontario website. The bill does not create an individual benefit or a process for residents to request asbestos removal.
Money#
No cost estimate is included in the available material.
- The bill would require the Minister to maintain and publish the register and allow the Minister to appoint inspectors, but it gives no staffing or operating-cost estimate.
- Building owners and lessees would have reporting duties; the bill does not estimate their costs.
- The bill does not set fine amounts. It allows regulations to set them.
What is unclear#
- The bill leaves reporting deadlines and fine amounts to regulations, which are not included in the supplied material. It also allows regulations to exempt people or groups from some reporting duties.
- The bill does not set out how reports would be checked, how often buildings would be inspected, or how the register’s accuracy would be ensured.
- Inspections of provincially owned or leased buildings could occur after a complaint. The bill does not describe a routine inspection schedule.
- The bill requires reports about work to reduce asbestos but does not say that the work must be completed before the register is updated.
- No information is supplied about how this bill would interact with existing Ontario laws or requirements concerning asbestos. The bill would start on Royal Assent if enacted.
Case for#
- A ban on the specified activities could be seen as a direct way to limit asbestos use and movement in Ontario.
- A public register could make information about asbestos in provincial public buildings easier to find.
- Requiring owners to report asbestos and updates about work could help keep that public information current.
- Inspection powers could help enforce the ban and reporting duties when a complaint is made.
Case against#
- The bill leaves important details, including deadlines and fine amounts, to future regulations. Those details could affect how workable and strong the rules are.
- Because inspections under the bill require a complaint, buildings may not be inspected under this law when no complaint is made.
- The bill does not estimate the public cost of the register, inspectors or enforcement, or the reporting costs for building owners.
- The exception depends on whether a person knows an existing product contains asbestos. The bill does not explain how that knowledge would be established in a particular case.