Charity Facility Tax Relief

Summary#

The Luso Canadian Charitable Society Act (Tax Relief), 2024 is a special Ontario law about one property at 922 Main Street East in Hamilton. It allows Hamilton’s council to exempt the property from municipal taxes and, as a result, school taxes, if the stated conditions are met; the goal is to support a facility offering not-for-profit day services and residential accommodation for people with physical or developmental disabilities.

  • Hamilton’s council may, but does not have to, pass a by-law granting the municipal tax exemption.
  • The exemption depends on the Society being the registered owner and a registered charity, and the property being used for developing and then providing the specified services.
  • The property may be used solely by the Society or jointly with eligible not-for-profit entities. Any portion used by another entity is not exempt.
  • If Hamilton grants the exemption, school taxes are also exempt for the same period.
  • If Hamilton passes a tax-cancellation by-law, municipal taxes, interest and penalties may be cancelled back to February 28, 2023. School taxes, interest and penalties are also cancelled for the same period.

What it means for you#

  • Luso Canadian Charitable Society: The Society does not receive an automatic exemption. It must meet the ownership, charity-status and use conditions, and Hamilton’s council must pass a by-law for the municipal exemption. The law does not require the Society to apply through a particular process.
  • City of Hamilton: Council may grant the exemption and may cancel eligible municipal taxes, interest and penalties. Local improvement rates are not covered.
  • School-tax authorities and taxpayers: If the municipal exemption is granted, school taxes are exempt for the same period. If municipal taxes are cancelled for a period, school taxes are cancelled for that period too.
  • People who may use the facility: The law supports the stated purpose of providing services and accommodation, but does not create a personal right to those services or set eligibility rules for them.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimate of the tax revenue affected.

  • Hamilton’s municipal revenue and school-tax revenue may be reduced if the relevant by-laws and conditions apply.
  • Tax cancellation may also remove interest and penalties. Local improvement rates remain payable.
  • The law does not provide a cost estimate or say whether the Society or City will incur other costs.

What is unclear#

  • Whether Hamilton’s council will pass either by-law, and when.
  • How the City would determine whether the property meets the conditions over time.
  • How tax exemption or cancellation would be calculated if only part of the property is used by an ineligible entity.
  • The text does not set out an application process, review schedule or appeal process.
  • The supplied material does not give the date Royal Assent was received.

Case for#

  • The law appears intended to reduce the property-tax burden on a registered charity developing a facility for people with physical or developmental disabilities.
  • Giving Hamilton’s council discretion allows the City to decide whether to grant the exemption.
  • Linking school-tax relief to the municipal exemption keeps the tax treatment aligned.
  • The conditions limit relief to the specified property and its stated charitable use.

Case against#

  • A possible trade-off is reduced municipal and school-tax revenue, including possible cancellation of past taxes, interest and penalties.
  • The law does not require the City to grant relief, so the Society may not receive it even if it meets the conditions.
  • The law does not explain how continued compliance or mixed use will be checked, which could leave important details to later decisions.