Municipal tax relief for charity land

Summary#

The Special Ability Riding Institute Act (Tax Relief), 2019 creates a special law for specified land owned by the Special Ability Riding Institute (SARI); it does not amend the Municipal Act, 2001. It allows Middlesex Centre’s council to grant municipal tax relief, and provides matching school-tax relief if council does so. The Act’s stated goal is to grant SARI’s application for tax relief; it took effect on Royal Assent.

  • Council may, but is not required to, exempt the specified land from municipal taxes starting January 1, 2019.
  • The exemption is available only while SARI is the registered owner, the land is occupied and used solely by SARI, and SARI is a registered charity.
  • If council grants the exemption, it may also cancel eligible municipal taxes for all or part of 2017 and 2018, and for parts of years covered by the exemption where taxes were levied. Interest and penalties can also be cancelled.
  • School taxes are exempt, and eligible school taxes can be cancelled, for the same periods as the corresponding municipal relief.
  • Any portion occupied and used by another entity is not covered. Local improvement rates are also excluded from the municipal relief.

What it means for you#

  • SARI: It can receive the tax relief only if all three conditions are met. The municipal exemption depends on council passing a by-law; the Act does not require council to do so.
  • Middlesex Centre: Council decides whether to grant the municipal exemption and whether to cancel eligible past taxes. The Act does not set a decision process.
  • School-tax recipients and other bodies: School-tax relief follows if council passes the relevant municipal by-law. The Act also applies a Municipal Act rule for taxes collected on behalf of other bodies to the cancelled school taxes.
  • Other taxpayers: The relief is limited to the specified land and does not directly change anyone else’s tax bill.

Money#

The available material gives no estimate of the revenue affected or the cost of administering the tax relief.

  • If council passes the by-laws, municipal and school-tax revenue may be reduced, including amounts of interest and penalties that are cancelled.
  • The amount depends on the taxes levied for the land and which periods council includes; no figures are provided.
  • The Act does not state a payment to SARI or a funding amount for the municipality.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not give the date of Royal Assent.
  • The text does not set out how council would decide whether to pass the by-laws, or require a public process, reasons, or reporting.
  • It does not say how the boundaries of any portion used by another entity would be determined.
  • The 1988 Special Ability Riding Institute Act already provided a tax exemption for land it described. Its text was not supplied, so the full extent of that existing exemption and its overlap with this Act could not be verified.
  • No estimate is provided for the tax revenue affected.

Case for#

  • The Act appears intended to give a named registered charity tax relief on specified land it owns and uses itself.
  • Letting council decide whether to grant the municipal relief leaves the decision with the municipality rather than making the exemption automatic.
  • Tying school-tax relief to the same periods as municipal relief gives the two forms of relief a consistent scope.
  • Excluding portions used by another entity limits the relief to land used solely by SARI.

Case against#

  • One concern is that council may cancel taxes for periods reaching back to 2017, including interest and penalties, reducing revenue that would otherwise have been collected.
  • The Act gives council discretion but does not explain what factors or process should guide its decision.
  • It does not provide a revenue estimate, so the size of the effect on municipal and school-tax revenue is unknown.
  • The conditions require sole use by SARI, but the Act does not explain how shared or changing uses would be assessed.