Bill mandates all-inclusive price disclosures

Summary#

Bill 28, the What You See is What You Pay Act (Consumer Protection Amendment), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Consumer Protection Act, 2002. Its stated goal is to require suppliers to show consumers the full cost of goods and services. The bill would start one year after receiving Royal Assent; the supplied material does not say whether or when that happened.

  • Suppliers would have to include the all-inclusive cost in any information they give consumers about a good or service’s cost. That total includes the price, HST and any other charges or fees.
  • If a supplier displays both a price and the all-inclusive cost, the all-inclusive cost must be in a font at least as large as the price.
  • For a promotional discount, suppliers would have to clearly state how long it lasts, in a font at least half the size of the font used for the price and all-inclusive cost.
  • The Minister could make regulations exempting suppliers, goods or services, or classes of them.
  • The Director could give a non-complying supplier a notice and require compliance within 30 days. If the supplier then fails to comply and is convicted, the bill sets a fine formula based partly on the all-inclusive cost of the highest-priced non-compliant good or service.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: When suppliers provide information about a good or service’s cost, that information would have to include the total amount payable, including HST and other charges or fees. The bill would not require suppliers to advertise or display a price, or prevent them from charging disclosed fees.
  • Suppliers: They would have to follow the disclosure and font-size rules unless regulations exempt them. A supplier that receives a notice would have 30 days to meet its requirements.
  • Suppliers facing a fine: After a conviction, the bill allows a written request to the Tribunal for a hearing within 30 days of receiving the Director’s fine notice. The Tribunal must hold a hearing and may confirm the fine, set it aside, or lower it.
  • Minister: The Minister could create exemptions by regulation. The bill does not require the Minister to do so.

Money#

No cost estimate or other public cost information is in the supplied material.

  • The bill gives no estimate of suppliers’ costs to change price displays or promotions, or of government costs to administer and enforce the rules.
  • It creates a fine formula, but the material does not estimate how much fines might raise.

What is unclear#

  • The Consumer Protection Act, 2002 itself was not supplied, so the bill’s changes could not be checked against current disclosure rules or enforcement procedures.
  • The bill does not define how promotional duration must be communicated beyond saying it must be clear.
  • It does not explain how exemptions might be decided or what suppliers, goods or services might be exempt.
  • The fine formula sets base amounts by business size, plus 100% of the all-inclusive cost of the highest-priced non-compliant good or service. The bill does not explain how that cost would be established in every case.
  • The start date depends on Royal Assent, which is not provided in the material.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that consumers could see the full amount they must pay when suppliers provide cost information, rather than having to add taxes and fees themselves.
  • Requiring the all-inclusive cost to be at least as prominent as a separately shown price could make it harder to draw attention to a lower price while making the total less visible.
  • Requiring the length of a promotional discount to be stated could help consumers understand how long the reduced price applies.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill sets font-size rules but does not give more detailed instructions for how suppliers must present prices or promotional periods.
  • The Minister’s power to exempt suppliers or classes of goods and services could leave some consumer transactions outside the rules; the bill does not set limits on those exemptions.
  • The bill adds compliance and enforcement work but gives no cost estimate. Its fine formula also depends partly on the cost of the highest-priced non-compliant item, which may be difficult to determine in some cases.