School boards must disclose site deals

Summary#

Bill 47, the School Boards Property and Development Transparency Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Education Act. Its stated goal is to make school boards’ dealings about school sites and construction more transparent.

  • Boards would have to tell the Education Minister and the public about school-site purchase agreements, including conditional agreements, within two business days. Notices must include the parties, price, conditions, the board’s reason, and intended uses of the site. Boards must report changes within two business days.
  • For proposals to provide pupil accommodation on a site not used exclusively by the board, boards would have to publish notices at several stages: when they apply to negotiate, when they propose an agreement to the Minister, when an approved agreement is made, and when it changes.
  • The notices would be required regardless of whether the relevant dealings are funded with legislative appropriations, education development charges, or accumulated surpluses.
  • A grant to a board for constructing facilities would come with a reporting condition: the board must post a progress report by the grant’s first anniversary and at least every six months afterward, and send each report to the Minister and the municipality where construction is taking place.
  • The bill allows regulations to require more notice information or other ways of making notices public. It does not itself set a start date; the Act would begin on a day set by proclamation.

What it means for you#

  • School boards: Boards would have to prepare and publish the required notices and construction progress reports. The bill adds disclosure duties; it does not itself change who may buy a site or use it.
  • The public: People could find specified information about site purchases and shared-use accommodation proposals on board websites and through any other prescribed public method.
  • The Minister of Education: The Minister would receive notice of site purchase agreements and changes, and receive construction progress reports. The bill also retains a role for the Minister to approve the relevant accommodation agreements.
  • Municipalities: The municipality where construction takes place would receive each progress report.
  • Students, families and taxpayers: The bill does not directly change school eligibility, services, taxes, or fees.

Money#

The bill requires boards to provide staff time and resources for notices and reports, but no cost estimate is available.

  • It sets no new tax, fee, fine, or amount of grant funding.
  • It does not estimate the cost of board reporting or any savings.

What is unclear#

  • The Education Act itself was not supplied, so the bill’s description of existing law and how these changes fit with it could not be checked against the current Act.
  • The bill does not set a start date; that would depend on a later proclamation.
  • It does not explain whether any information may be withheld or redacted, including details about parties, prices, and negotiation terms.
  • It does not define what counts as a progress report or set out what construction information each report must contain.
  • The bill does not set out enforcement, penalties, or a process for the public to challenge missing or incomplete notices.

Case for#

  • Publishing the parties, prices, conditions, reasons, and intended uses could help the public understand major school-board property decisions.
  • Notices at multiple stages could make proposed shared-use arrangements visible before and after the Minister’s approval.
  • Regular construction reports could give the public, the Minister, and the municipality updates on facilities built with grant funding.

Case against#

  • One concern is that publishing detailed terms within two business days could reveal sensitive information while a deal or negotiation is still underway.
  • The bill requires progress reports but does not specify their contents, which could make the information less useful or consistent.
  • The bill gives the government power to add notice requirements by regulation, but does not set limits on what further information may be required.