Bill Ends Public Funding for Partisan Ads

Summary#

Bill 176, the End the Public Funding of Partisan Government Advertising Act, 2024, would amend Ontario’s Government Advertising Act, 2004; it would not create a separate law or agency. Its stated goal is to end public funding of partisan government advertising. The explanatory note says it would reverse changes made in 2015, but the 2004 Act itself was not supplied, so the current rules could not be checked against the bill.

  • Government offices could not publish, distribute or convey an item while it is under review, or after the Auditor General says it fails the standards. If the review deadline is missed, the item is treated as meeting the standards.
  • The standards would require an item to serve one or more listed public purposes, say it is paid for by the Government of Ontario, and not be partisan or primarily promote the governing party or damage its critics.
  • An item could not include an Ontario cabinet member’s or MPP’s name, voice or image, unless its primary target audience is outside Ontario.
  • During specified general-election periods, government offices could not use items even if approved. Exceptions include revenue-generating or time-sensitive items; existing items must stop unless the office head considers stopping them impracticable.
  • The Auditor General must review items submitted for review and decide whether they meet the standards. The bill also allows additional standards and factors to be set by regulation.

What it means for you#

  • People who see government advertising: You would see fewer government items that fail the standards or fall within the election-period restriction. The bill does not ban all government advertising.
  • Ontario government offices: They would have to wait for the review result before using an item and could not use one the Auditor General finds fails. A revised item would need another review. The bill does not set the review deadline; if the deadline is missed, the item is treated as approved.
  • Auditor General’s Office: It would have to review items submitted and assess whether they meet the standards. This bill does not create a new independent body.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not directly change taxes, fees or benefits.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The Auditor General’s Office would have review work, and government offices would have to follow the review and election-period rules. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The bill does not specify an appropriation (money set aside) or change taxes or fees.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves the review deadlines, extra advertising standards, decision factors and some election-period exceptions to regulations.
  • It does not explain how the Auditor General would resolve borderline cases, or whether offices could appeal a finding.
  • The meaning of “time sensitive” is not defined in the bill.
  • The parent Act was not supplied, so the bill’s full effect compared with current law cannot be verified. The explanatory note says it reverses 2015 changes.
  • The bill would start on a day set by proclamation; no start date is given.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that public money should not pay for advertising whose main purpose is to promote the governing party or attack its critics.
  • Requiring review before use, and barring items that fail, could provide a check before public funds are spent on them.
  • The election-period restrictions could reduce the use of government advertising during a campaign, while retaining exceptions for some necessary or revenue-generating messages.
  • The deemed-approval rule could prevent review delays from holding up an item indefinitely.

Case against#

  • The Auditor General would have room to judge an item’s primary objective and consider additional factors. The bill does not fully specify how those judgments would be made.
  • Review deadlines and key rules would be set later by regulation, so the bill alone does not show how quickly reviews would happen or how exceptions would work.
  • If the review deadline is missed, an item is treated as meeting the standards without a completed decision.
  • A possible trade-off is that the restrictions could delay or stop useful government information, including during an election period.