Tax relief for a single property

Summary#

The Luso Canadian Charitable Society Act (Tax Relief), 2018 is a special Act for one property in Mississauga. It authorizes the City of Mississauga to exempt the property from some taxes, and to cancel certain past taxes; the stated goal is to grant the Society’s application for tax relief. The supplied material indicates the Act received Royal Assent and took effect on that day, but does not give the date.

  • The City may, but does not have to, pass a by-law exempting the property at 6245 Mississauga Road from municipal taxes starting January 1, 2018. Local improvement rates are not exempt.
  • The exemption depends on the Society being the registered owner and a registered charity, and the property being used to operate a not-for-profit facility for people with physical or developmental disabilities.
  • The property may be used solely by the Society or jointly with qualifying not-for-profit entities. However, a portion occupied and used by an entity other than the Society is not exempt.
  • If the City passes the exemption by-law, school taxes are also exempt for the same period.
  • If the City passes the municipal tax-cancellation by-law, it may cancel municipal taxes, interest and penalties for all or part of 2016 and 2017, and for eligible periods when taxes were levied. Corresponding school taxes, interest and penalties are also cancelled.

What it means for you#

  • The Society: It can receive this tax relief only if the listed ownership, charity, use and facility conditions are met, and the City passes the required by-law or by-laws. The Act does not automatically grant the relief.
  • The City of Mississauga: Council may decide whether to pass the municipal exemption by-law. A separate by-law is needed to cancel taxes.
  • Other users of the property: A portion occupied and used by an entity other than the Society does not qualify for the exemption or tax cancellation under this Act.
  • Other taxpayers and the public: The Act concerns taxes on this property. It does not directly change anyone else’s taxes, create a new service, or exempt local improvement rates.

Money#

No cost estimate or revenue estimate is in the available material.

  • The Act allows municipal and school taxes, plus interest and penalties, to be exempted or cancelled for the specified property if the conditions and by-law requirements are met.
  • It gives no estimate of the value of the relief or its effect on municipal or school-tax revenues.
  • It says the Municipal Act, 2001 rule on taxes collected for other bodies applies, with necessary changes, to cancelled school taxes. The amount or practical effect of that rule is not stated here.

What is unclear#

  • Whether the City passed either by-law, and what tax relief, if any, the Society received.
  • The value of the taxes that could be exempted or cancelled.
  • How any portions used by other entities would be identified and assessed in practice.
  • The date of Royal Assent is not given in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • The Act appears intended to reduce the tax burden on a not-for-profit facility serving people with physical or developmental disabilities.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that it gives the City discretion to grant relief while tying eligibility to the property’s ownership, charitable status and use.
  • The relief is limited to one named property and does not apply to local improvement rates.

Case against#

  • The exemption and cancellation could reduce municipal and school-tax revenue, but the available material gives no estimate of the amount.
  • The Act allows cancellation of past taxes, interest and penalties, including for 2016 and 2017.
  • The City may choose whether to grant the relief, so the Act itself does not guarantee it.
  • The Act does not explain how the qualifying use or any portions used by other entities would be assessed in practice.